# How did we get here

- Link: https://kendreger.com/?p=783
- Published: 2025-03-14T19:50:29+07:00
- Author: ken

# **Deep Dive into where we are in 2025 with the Ukraine issue**

---

![](https://kendreger.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/security-2.jpg)

### Background

The Belovezha Accords emerged amid the Soviet Union’s rapid decline in the late 
1980s and early 1990s. Several factors set the stage:

 * **Gorbachev’s Reforms:** Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev introduced _glasnost_(
   openness) and _perestroika_ (restructuring) to modernize the USSR. While these
   policies aimed to revitalize the system, they instead fueled nationalist movements
   and exposed deep economic and political weaknesses.
 * **Economic Collapse:** By 1991, the Soviet economy was in freefall—widespread
   shortages, a plummeting ruble, and systemic inefficiencies crippled daily life,
   eroding public faith in the central government.
 * **Nationalism and Independence:** Republics such as Ukraine, Belarus, and the
   Baltic states increasingly sought autonomy or outright independence, driven by
   decades of suppressed national identity.
 * **August 1991 Coup:** A failed coup by hardline communists against Gorbachev 
   in August 1991 weakened his authority and accelerated the disintegration of central
   power. Boris Yeltsin, president of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic(
   RSFSR), emerged as a key figure opposing the coup, boosting his influence.
 * **Legal Precedent:** The three signatory republics—Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus—
   were original founders of the USSR under the 1922 Treaty on the Creation of the
   USSR. Their coordinated exit carried symbolic and legal weight in dissolving 
   the union they had helped form.

By late 1991, Gorbachev’s efforts to preserve the USSR through a new Union Treaty
were faltering. The Belovezha Accords delivered the decisive blow.

### The Signing

The Belovezha Accords were signed on December 8, 1991, at a government hunting lodge
near Viskuli in the Belovezhskaya Pushcha National Park, a remote forest in western
Belarus. The key participants were:

 * **Russia:** President Boris Yeltsin and First Deputy Prime Minister Gennady Burbulis.
 * **Ukraine:** President Leonid Kravchuk.
 * **Belarus:** Chairman of the Supreme Soviet Stanislav Shushkevich and Prime Minister
   Vyacheslav Kebich.

Initially framed as a discussion on economic cooperation and energy supplies (e.
g., oil and gas flows to Ukraine and Belarus), the meeting quickly pivoted to a 
more radical agenda: dissolving the Soviet Union entirely. The decision was bold
and somewhat spontaneous, driven by Yeltsin’s ambition to assert Russia’s dominance
and Kravchuk’s push for Ukrainian independence, following a December 1 referendum
in which 90% of Ukrainians voted for sovereignty.

The document itself was drafted rapidly, with input from legal advisors such as 
Russia’s Sergei Shakhrai. It was concise—only 14 articles—reflecting the urgency
and the need for a clear, immediate declaration rather than a detailed treaty.

### Content of the Accords

The Belovezha Accords (officially titled the _Agreement Establishing the Commonwealth
of Independent States_) consisted of a preamble and 14 articles. Below is a breakdown:

#### **Preamble**

 * Declared that “the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, as a subject of international
   law and a geopolitical reality, is ceasing its existence.”
 * Stated that the signatories were acting based on “historical commonality” and
   the will of their peoples (e.g., Ukraine’s referendum).

#### **Key Articles**

 * **Formation of the CIS (Article 1):** Established the Commonwealth of Independent
   States as a voluntary association of sovereign states, not a successor state 
   to the USSR.
 * **Sovereignty (Article 2):** Affirmed the independence and territorial integrity
   of each signatory state, guaranteeing mutual recognition of borders.
 * **End of Soviet Laws (Article 5):** Stated that USSR laws would no longer apply
   in the signatories’ territories after ratification, though transitional coordination
   was implied.
 * **Cooperation (Articles 6-7):** Committed the states to collaborate on defense,
   economic policy, and foreign affairs within the CIS framework, including maintaining
   a unified military command temporarily.
 * **Human Rights (Article 4):** Pledged adherence to international norms on human
   rights and freedoms.
 * **Open Membership (Article 9):** Allowed other former Soviet republics to join
   the CIS if they accepted the accords’ terms.
 * **Nuclear Weapons (Article 6):** Addressed the USSR’s nuclear arsenal, with an
   implicit understanding (later formalized) that Russia would inherit control, 
   while Ukraine, Belarus, and Kazakhstan would eventually denuclearize.

The accords avoided micromanaging practicalities, leaving issues like currency, 
trade, and military division to future negotiations.

### Immediate Aftermath

#### **Ratification**

 * **Belarus:** Ratified on December 10, 1991.
 * **Ukraine:** Ratified on December 10, 1991.
 * **Russia:** Ratified on December 12, 1991.

These swift approvals cemented the accords’ legitimacy.

#### **Gorbachev’s Reaction**

Gorbachev called the accords illegal, arguing that dissolving the USSR required 
broader consent from all 15 republics and a constitutional process. However, he 
lacked the power to reverse them.

#### **Global Notification**

Yeltsin called U.S. President George H.W. Bush on December 8 to inform him of the
decision, emphasizing stability (e.g., nuclear control under Russia). The West largely
welcomed the end of the Soviet threat.

#### **Alma-Ata Protocol**

On December 21, 1991, 11 of the 15 former Soviet republics met in Almaty, Kazakhstan,
and signed a protocol expanding the CIS, formalizing the USSR’s end. Gorbachev resigned
on December 25, and the Soviet flag was lowered from the Kremlin that night.

### **Implications**

#### **End of the Cold War**

The accords dismantled the USSR, ending the bipolar world order dominated by the
U.S.-Soviet rivalry.

#### **Russia as Successor**

Russia inherited the USSR’s UN Security Council seat, nuclear arsenal, and much 
of its international standing, though its territory and influence were significantly
reduced.

#### **Independence Movements**

The accords emboldened other republics (e.g., Georgia, Armenia, the Baltics) to 
solidify their independence, though some faced conflicts (e.g., Chechnya, Nagorno-
Karabakh).

#### **Economic and Social Chaos**

The abrupt dissolution triggered economic turmoil—hyperinflation, unemployment, 
and disrupted trade—across the former Soviet space.

### **Legacy**

#### **Historical Milestone**

The Belovezha Accords are seen as one of the 20th century’s most consequential agreements,
reshaping global geopolitics.

#### **Controversy**

Some, especially in Russia, later criticized Yeltsin and the signatories for acting
rashly, blaming them for post-Soviet instability. Nostalgia for the USSR persists
in parts of the region.

#### **CIS Weakness**

The Commonwealth of Independent States never became a strong unifying body, as national
interests diverged, and some members (e.g., Ukraine) distanced themselves over time.

### **Fun Fact**

The name “Belovezha” comes from the Belovezhskaya Pushcha forest, a UNESCO site 
famous for its bison and pristine wilderness. The serene setting sharply contrasted
with the monumental decision made there.

---

This revision corrects grammatical issues, improves flow, and enhances clarity while
preserving the integrity of your original content. Let me know if you need further
refinements!
