# July 6th 2020 Crap

- Link: https://kendreger.com/?p=511
- Published: 2022-07-13T08:30:32+07:00
- Author: ken

**July 12 hearing of the House select committee investigating the Jan. 6 Capitol
attack**

**Below, read the full transcript from the July 12 hearing of the House select committee
investigating the Jan. 6 Capitol attack. The transcript was produced by CQ.**

House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States
Capitol Holds Hearing on January 6th Investigation

BENNIE THOMPSON:

The Select Committee to investigate the January 6th attack on the United States 
Capitol will be in order. Without objection, the chair is authorized to declare 
the committee in recess at any point. Pursuant to House Deposition Authority Regulation
10, the chair announces the committee’s approval to release the deposition material
presented during today’s hearing.

Good afternoon. When I think about the most basic way to explain the importance 
of elections in the United States, there’s a phrase that always comes to mind. It
may sound straightforward, but it’s meaningful. We settle our differences at the
ballot box. Sometimes my choice prevails, sometimes yours does, but it’s that simple.

We cast our votes. We count the votes. If something seems off with the results, 
we can challenge them in court, and then we accept the results. When you’re on the
losing side, that doesn’t mean you have to be happy about it. And in the United 
States, there’s plenty you can do and say so. You can protest.

You can organize. You can get ready for the next election to try to make sure your
side has a better chance the next time the people settle their differences at the
ballot box. But you can’t turn violent. You can’t try to achieve your desired outcome
through force or harassment or intimidation. Any real leader who sees their supporters
going down that path, approaching that line has a responsibility to say stop, we
gave it our best, we came up short, we try again next time, because we settle our
differences at the ballot box.

On December 14th, 2020, the presidential election was officially over. The Electoral
College had cast its vote. Joe Biden was the president-elect of the United States.
By that point, many of Donald Trump’s supporters were already convinced that the
election had been stolen because that’s what Donald Trump had been telling them.

So, what Donald Trump was required to do in that moment, what would have been required
of any American leader, was to say we did our best and we came up short. He went
the opposite way. He seized on the anger he had already stoked among his most loyal
supporters. And as they approached the line, he didn’t wave them off.

He urged them on. Today the committee will explain how, as a part of his last-ditch
effort to overturn the election and block the transfer of power, Donald Trump summoned
a mob to Washington DC and ultimately spurred that mob to wage a violent attack 
on our democracy. Our colleagues, Ms. Murphy of Florida and Mr. Raskin of Maryland,
will lay out this story.

First, I’m pleased to recognize our distinguished vice chair, Ms. Cheney of Wyoming,
for any opening comments she’d care to offer.

LIZ CHENEY: Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Our committee did not conduct a hearing
last week, but we did conduct an on the record interview of President Trump’s former
White House counsel, Pat Cipollone. If you’ve watched these hearings, you’ve heard
us call for Mr. Cipollone to come forward to testify. He did, and Mr. Cipollone’s
testimony met our expectations.

We will save for our next hearing President Trump’s behavior during the violence
of January 6th. Today’s hearing will take us from December 14th, 2020, when the 
Electoral College met and certified the results of the 2020 presidential election,
up through the morning of January 6th. You will see certain segments of Pat Cipollone’s
testimony today. We will also see today how President Trump summoned a mob to Washington
and how the president’s stolen election lies provoked that mob to attack the Capitol.
And we will hear from a man who was induced by President Trump’s lies to come to
Washington and join the mob and how that decision has changed his life.

Today’s hearing is our seventh. We have covered significant ground over the past
several weeks, and we have also seen a change in how witnesses and lawyers in the
Trump orbit approach this committee. Initially, their strategy in some cases appeared
to be to deny and delay. Today there appears to be a general recognition that the
committee has established key facts, including that virtually everyone close to 
President Trump, his Justice Department officials, his White House advisers, his
White House counsel, his campaign, all told him the 2020 election was not stolen.

This appears to have changed the strategy for defending Donald Trump. Now the argument
seems to be that President Trump was manipulated by others outside the administration,
that he was persuaded to ignore his closest advisers, and that he was incapable 
of telling right from wrong. This new strategy is to try to blame only John Eastman
or Sidney Powell or Congressman Scott Perry or others and not President Trump.

In this version, the president was “poorly served” by these outside advisers. The
strategy is to blame people his advisers called “the crazies” for what Donald Trump
did. This, of course, is nonsense. President Trump is a 76 year old man. He is not
an impressionable child. Just like everyone else in our country, he is responsible
for his own actions and his own choices.

As our investigation has shown, Donald Trump had access to more detailed and specific
information showing that the election was not actually stolen than almost any other
American, and he was told this over and over again. No rational or sane man in his
position could disregard that information and reach the opposite conclusion.

Donald Trump cannot escape responsibility by being willfully blind, nor can any 
argument of any kind excuse President Trump’s behavior during the violent attack
on January 6th. As you watch our hearing today, I would urge you to keep your eye
on two specific points. First, you will see evidence that Trump’s legal team, led
by Rudy Giuliani, knew that they lacked actual evidence of widespread fraud sufficient
to prove that the election was actually stolen.

They knew it, but they went ahead with January 6th anyway. And second, consider 
how millions of Americans were persuaded to believe what Donald Trump’s closest 
advisers in his administration did not. These Americans did not have access to the
truth like Donald Trump did. They put their faith and their trust in Donald Trump.

They wanted to believe in him. They wanted to fight for their country, and he deceived
them. For millions of Americans, that may be painful to accept, but it is true. 
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back.

BENNIE THOMPSON: Without objection, the chair recognizes the gentlewoman from Florida,
Ms. Murphy, and the gentleman from Maryland, Mr. Raskin, for opening statements.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We know beyond a shadow of a doubt that
then President Donald Trump lost in a free and fair election, and yet President 
Trump insisted that his loss was due to fraud in the election process rather than
to the democratic will of the voters. The president continued to make this claim
despite being told again and again by the courts, by the Justice Department, by 
his campaign officials, and by some of his closest advisers that the evidence did
not support this assertion.

This was the big lie, and millions of Americans were deceived by it. Too many of
our fellow citizens still believe it to this day. It’s corrosive to our country 
and damaging to our democracy. As our committee has shown in prior hearings, following
the election, President Trump relentlessly pursued multiple interlocking lines of
effort, all with a single goal, to remain in power despite having lost. The lines
of effort were aimed at his loyal vice president, Mike Pence, at state election 
and elected officials, and at the US Department of Justice. The president pressured
the vice president to obstruct the process to certify the election result. He demanded
that state officials find him enough votes to overturn the election outcome in that
state, and he pressed the Department of Justice to find widespread evidence of fraud.

When Justice officials told the president that such evidence did not exist, the 
president urged them to simply declare that the election was corrupt. On December
14th, the Electoral College met to officially confirm that Joe Biden would be the
next president. The evidence shows that once this occurred, President Trump and 
those who were willing to aid and abet him turned their attention to the joint session
of Congress scheduled for January 6th at which the vice president would preside.

In their warped view, this ceremonial event was the next and perhaps the last inflection
point that could be used to reverse the outcome of the election before Mr. Biden’s
inauguration. As President Trump put it, the vice president and enough members of
Congress simply needed to summon the courage to act.

To help them find that courage, the president called for backup. Early in the morning
of December 19th, the president sent out a tweet urging his followers to travel 
to Washington DC for January 6th. Be there, will be wild, the president wrote. As
my colleague, Mr. Raskin, will describe in detail, this tweet served as a call to
action and in some cases as a call to arms for many of President Trump’s most loyal
supporters.

It’s clear the president intended the assembled crowd on the — January 6th to serve
his goal. And as you’ve already seen and as you will see again today, some of those
who were coming had specific plans. The president’s goal was to stay in power for
a second term despite losing the election. The assembled crowd was one of the tools
to achieve that goal.

In today’s hearing, we will focus on events that took place in the final weeks leading
up to January 6th, starting in mid-December, and we’ll add color and context to 
evidence you’ve already heard about and will also provide additional new evidence.
For example, you’ll hear about meetings in which the president entertained extreme
measures designed to help him stay in power like the seizure of voting machines.

We will show some of the coordination that occurred between the White House and 
members of Congress as it relates to January 6th, and some of these members of Congress
would later seek pardons. We will also examine some of the planning for the January
6th protests, placing special emphasis on one rally planner’s concerns about the
potential violence.

And we will describe some of the president’s key actions on the evening of January
5th and the morning of January 6th, including how the president edited and adlibbed
his speech that morning at the Ellipse, directed the crowd to march to the Capitol,
and spoke off script in a way that further inflamed an already angry crowd.

I yield to the gentleman from Maryland, Mr. Raskin.

JAMIE RASKIN: Thank you, Ms. Murphy, Mr. Chairman, Madam Vice Chair. Four days after
the electors met across the country and made Joe Biden the president elect, Donald
Trump was still trying to find a way to hang on to the presidency. On Friday, December
18th, his team of outside advisers paid him a surprise visit in the White House 
that would quickly become the stuff of legend.

The meeting has been called unhinged, not normal and the craziest meeting of the
Trump presidency. The outside lawyers who’d been involved in dozens of failed lawsuits
had lots of theories supporting the big lie, but no evidence to support it. As we
will see, however, they brought to the White House a draft executive order that 
they had prepared for President Trump to further his ends.

Specifically, they proposed the immediate mass seizure of state election machines
by the US military. The meeting ended after midnight with apparent rejection of 
that idea. In the wee hours of December 19th, dissatisfied with his options, Donald
Trump decided to call for a large and wild crowd on Wednesday, January 6th, the 
day when Congress would meet to certify the electoral votes.

Never before in American history had a president called for a crowd to come contest
the counting of electoral votes by Congress or engaged in any effort designed to
influence, delay, or obstruct the joint session of Congress in doing its work required
by our Constitution and the Electoral Count Act. As we’ll see, Donald Trump’s 1:
42 AM tweet electrified and galvanized his supporters, especially the dangerous 
extremists in the Oath Keepers, the Proud Boys, and other racist and white nationalist
groups spoiling for a fight against the government.

Three rings of interwoven attack were now operating towards January 6th. On the 
inside ring, Trump continued trying to work to overturn the election by getting 
Mike Pence to abandon his oath of office as vice president and assert the unilateral
power to reject electoral votes. This would have been a fundamental and unprecedented
breach of the Constitution that would promise Trump multiple ways of staying in 
office.

Meanwhile, in the middle ring, members of domestic violent extremist groups created
an alliance both online and in-person to coordinate a massive effort to storm, invade,
and occupy the Capitol. By placing a target on the joint session of Congress, Trump
had mobilized these groups around a common goal, emboldening them, strengthening
their working relationships, and helping build their numbers.

Finally, in the outer ring, on January 6th there assembled a large and angry crowd,
the political force that Trump considered both the touchstone and the measure of
his political power. Here were thousands of enraged Trump followers thoroughly convinced
by the big lie, who traveled from across the country to join Trump’s wild rally 
to stop the steal.

With the proper incitement by political leaders and the proper instigation from 
the extremists, many members of this crowd could be led to storm the Capitol, confront
the vice president and Congress, and try to overturn the 2020 election results. 
All of these efforts would converge and explode on January the 6th. Mr. Chairman,
as you know better than any other member of this committee from the wrenching struggle
for voting rights in your beloved Mississippi, the problem of politicians whipping
up mob violence to destroy fair elections is the oldest domestic enemy of constitutional
democracy in America.

Abraham Lincoln knew it too. In 1837, a racist mob in Alton, Illinois broke into
the offices of an abolitionist newspaper and killed its editor, Elijah Lovejoy. 
Lincoln wrote a speech in which he said that no transatlantic military giant could
ever crush us as a nation, even with all of the fortunes in the world.

But if downfall ever comes to America, he said, we ourselves would be its author
and finisher. If racist mobs are encouraged by politicians to rampage and terrorize,
Lincoln said, they will violate the rights of other citizens and quickly destroy
the bonds of social trust necessary for democracy to work.

Mobs and demagogues will put us on a path to political tyranny, Lincoln said. As
we’ll see today, this very old problem has returned with new ferocity today, as 
a president who lost an election deployed a mob, which included dangerous extremists,
to attack the constitutional system of election and the peaceful transfer of power.

As we’ll see, the creation of the Internet and social media has given today’s tyrants
tools of propaganda and disinformation that yesterday’s despots could only have 
dreamed of. I yield back to the gentlelady from Florida, Ms. Murphy.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Article Two of the United States Constitution establishes the 
Electoral College. Each state’s laws provide that electors are to be chosen by a
popular vote. And on December 14th, 2020, electors met in all 50 states and the 
District of Columbia to cast their votes. Joseph Biden won by a margin of 306 to
232. The election was over.

Mr. Biden was the president-elect. Before the Electoral College met, Donald Trump
and his allies filed dozens of legal challenges to the election, but they lost over
and over, again including in front of multiple judges — President Trump had nominated
to the bench. In many of these cases, the judges were highly critical of the arguments
put forward, explaining that no genuine evidence of widespread fraud had been presented.
For example, a federal judge in Pennsylvania said, this court has been presented
with strained legal arguments without merit and speculative accusations unsupported
by evidence. In the United States of America, this cannot justify the disenfranchisement
of a single voter, let alone all the voters of its six most populated states.

On December 15th after the Electoral College certified the outcome, the Republican
majority leader in the Senate acknowledged Mr. Biden’s victory. [Begin videotape]

MITCH MCCONNELL: Yesterday, electors met in all 50 states. So as of this morning,
our country has officially a President-elect and a Vice President-elect. Many millions
of us had hoped the Presidential election would yield a different result. But our
system of government has processes to determine who will be sworn in on January 
the 20th. The Electoral College has spoken.

So today, I want to congratulate President-elect Joe Biden. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Even members of President Trump’s Cabinet and his White House 
staff understood the significance of his losses in the courts and the absence of
evidence of fraud. They also respected the constitutional certification by the Electoral
College. Many of them told President Trump that it was time to concede the election
to Mr. Biden.

For example, then Secretary of Labor Gene Scalia, an accomplished lawyer and the
son of late Justice Scalia called President Trump in mid-December and advised him
to concede and accept the rulings of the courts. [Begin videotape]

GENE SCALIA: So I had to put a call into the President. I might have called on the
13th. We spoke, I believe, on the 14th in which I conveyed to him that I thought
that it was time for him to acknowledge that President Biden had prevailed in the
election. But I communicated to the President that when that legal process is exhausted
and when the electors have voted, that that’s the point at which that outcome needs
to be expected.

I told him that I did believe yes, that once those legal processes were run, if 
fraud had not been established that had affected the outcome of the election, then
unfortunately, I believed that what had to be done was concede the outcome. [End
videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: As you’ve seen in prior hearings, President Trump’s Justice Department,
his White House staff, and his campaign officials were repeatedly telling him that
there was no evidence of fraud sufficient to change the outcome of the election.
And last week, we conducted an eight-hour interview with President Trump’s White
House Counsel, Pat Cipollone.

You’ll see a number of excerpts of that interview today and even more in our next
hearing. Mr. Cipollone told us that he agreed with the testimony that there was 
no evidence of fraud sufficient to overturn the election. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: I want to start by asking if you agree, Mr. Cipollone, with the conclusion
of Matt Morgan and Bill Barr, of all of the individuals who evaluated those claims
that there is no evidence of election fraud sufficient to undermine the outcome 
in any particular state?

PAT CIPOLLONE: Yes, I agree with that. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: And Mr. Cipollone also specifically testified that he believed
that Donald Trump should have conceded the election. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: Did you believe, Mr. Cipollone, that the President should concede once 
you made the determination based on the investigations that you credited — DOJ did.
Did you in your mind form the belief that the President should concede the election
loss at a certain point after The election.

PAT CIPOLLONE: Well, again, I was the White House counsel. Some of those decisions
are political. So to the extent that — But — but if your question is did I believe
he should concede the election at a point in time? Yes, I did. I believe Leader 
McConnell went on to the floor of the Senate, I believe in late December, and basically
said, you know, the process is done.

You know, that would be in line with my thinking on these things. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: As Attorney General Bill Barr testified, December 14 should have
been the end of the matter. [Begin videotape]

WILLIAM BARR: December 14th was the day that the states certified their votes and
sent them to Congress. And in my view, that was the end of the matter. I didn’t 
see — you know, I thought that this would lead inexorably to a new administration.[
End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Mr. Cipollone also testified that the President’s Chief of Staff
Mark Meadows said he shared this view. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: As early as that November 23rd meeting, we understand that there was discussion
about the President possibly conceding the election. And specifically, we understand
that Mark

Meadows assured both you and Attorney General Barr that the President would eventually
agree to a graceful exit. Do you remember Mr. Meadows making any such representation?

PAT CIPOLLONE: Are you saying as part of that meeting or separately? Again, without—
without getting into that meeting, I would say that that is a — that is a statement
and a sentiment that I heard from Mark Meadows.

UNKNOWN: I see. And again, do you know if it was on November 23rd or some point?

PAT CIPOLLONE: Again, I — it was probably, you know, around that time and it was
probably subsequent to that time. It wasn’t a one-time statement. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Mr. Meadows has refused to testify and the committee is in litigation
with him. But many other White House officials shared the view that once the litigation
ended and the Electoral College met, the election was over. And here is President
Trump’s former press secretary. [Begin videotape]

LIZ CHENEY: I wanted to clarify, Ms. McEnany. So back to my previous question. It
was your view then — or was it your view that the efforts to overturn the election
should have stopped once the litigation was complete?

KAYLEIGH MCENANY: In my view, upon the conclusion of litigation was when I began
to plan for life after the administration. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: And this is what Ivanka Trump told us. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: December 14th was the day on which the Electoral College met. When these
electors around the country met and cast the electoral votes consistent with the—
the popular vote in each state. And it was obviously a public proceeding or a series
of proceedings that President Biden had obtained the requisite number of electors.

Was that an important day for you? Did that affect sort of your planning or your
realization as to whether or not there was going to be an end of this administration?

IVANKA TRUMP: I think so. I think it was my — my sentiment probably prior as well.[
End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Judd Deere was a White House deputy press secretary. This was 
his testimony about what he told President Trump. [Begin videotape]

JUDD DEERE: I told him that my personal viewpoint was that the Electoral College
had met, which is the system that our country is — is set under to elect a President
and Vice President. And I believed at that point that the means for him to pursue
litigation was probably closed.

UNKNOWN: And do you recall what his response, if any, was?

JUDD DEERE: He disagreed. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: We’ve also seen this testimony from Attorney General Barr, reflecting
a view of the White House staff in late November 2020. [Begin videotape]

WILLIAM BARR: And then at that point I left. And as I walked out of the Oval Office,
Jared was there with Dan Scavino who ran his — who ran the President’s social media
and who I thought was a reasonable guy, and believe is a reasonable guy. And I said
how long is — how long is he going to carry on with this stolen election stuff?

Where is this going to go? And by that time, Meadows had caught up with me and —
leaving the office and caught up to me and said that — he said, look, I think that
he’s becoming more realistic and knows that there’s a limit to how far he can take
this. And then Jared said, you know, yeah, we’re working on this.

We’re working on it. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Likewise in this testimony. Cassidy Hutchinson, an aide to Mark
Meadows, described her conversations with President Trump’s Director of National
Intelligence, John Ratcliffe, a former Republican Congressman. [Begin videotape]

CASSIDY HUTCHINSON: He had expressed that he was concerned that it could spiral 
out of control and potentially be dangerous, either for our democracy or the way
that things were going for the 6th. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Of course, underlying all of this is the fundamental principle
that the President of the United States cannot simply disregard the rulings of state
and federal courts which are empowered to address specific election related claims.
The President cannot simply pretend that the courts had not ruled. [Begin videotape]

LIZ CHENEY: By that time, the President or his associates had brought — had lost
60 out of 61 cases that they had brought to challenge different aspects of the election
in a number of states. They lost 60 out of 61 of those cases. So by the time we 
get to January 3rd, that’s — that’s been clear. I assume, Pat, that you would agree
the President is — is obligated to abide by the rulings of the courts.

PAT CIPOLLONE: Of course.

LIZ CHENEY: And I assume you also —

PAT CIPOLLONE: Everybody is obligated to abide by rules of courts.

LIZ CHENEY: And I assume you also would agree the President has a particular obligation
to take care that the laws be faithfully executed.

PAT CIPOLLONE: That is one of the President’s obligations, correct. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Yet President Trump disregarded these court rulings and the counsel
from his closest advisors, and continued his efforts to cling to power. In our prior
hearings, you have heard considerable testimony about President Trump’s attempts
to corruptly pressure Vice President Pence to refuse to count electoral votes, to
corrupt the Department of Justice, to pressure state officials in state legislatures,
and to create and submit a series of fake electoral slates.

Now, we will show you what other actions President Trump was taking between December
14, 2020 and January 6th. I yield to the gentleman from Maryland, Mr. Raskin.

JAMIE RASKIN: Thank you, Ms. Murphy. Throughout our hearings, you’ve heard how President
Trump made baseless claims that voting machines were being manipulated by foreign
powers in the 2020 election. You’ve also heard Trump’s Attorney General Bill Barr
describe such claims as complete nonsense, which he told the President.

Let’s review that testimony. [Begin videotape]

WILLIAM BARR: I saw absolutely zero basis for the allegations, but they were made
in such a sensational way that they obviously were influencing a lot of people, 
members of the public, that there was this systemic corruption in the system and
that their votes didn’t count and that these machines controlled by somebody else
were actually determining it, which was complete nonsense.

And it was being laid out there, and I told them that it was — that it was crazy
stuff and they were wasting their time on that. And it was doing a grave disservice
to the country. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: We’ve learned that President Trump’s White House counsel agreed with
the Department of Justice about this. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: Attorney General Barr made a public announcement on December 1st, less 
than a month after the election, that he had seen no systemic fraud [Inaudible].
Is it fair to say that by December 1st, you had reached the same conclusion?

PAT CIPOLLONE: It’s fair to say that I agreed with attorney general’s — Attorney
General Barr’s conclusion on December 1st. Yes, I did. And I supported that conclusion.[
End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: However, the strong rejection of the attorney general and the White
House counsel of these claims did not stop the President from trying to press them
in public. But that’s not all he did. Indeed, as you’ll see in this clip, the President
asked Attorney General Bill Barr to have the Department of Justice seize voting 
machines in the states. [Begin videotape]

WILLIAM BARR: My recollection is the President said something like, well, we could
get to the bottom — you know, some people say we could get to the bottom of this
if — if the department sees the machines. It was a typical way of raising a point.
And I said, absolutely not. There’s no probable cause and I’m not going to seize
any machines.

And that was that.

UNKNOWN: Yeah. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: But this wasn’t the end of the matter. On the evening of December 
18, 2020, Sidney Powell, General Michael Flynn and others entered the White House
for an unplanned meeting with the President. The meeting that would last multiple
hours and become hot blooded and contentious. The executive order behind me on the
screen was drafted on December the 16th, just two days after the Electoral College
vote by several of the President’s outside advisors over a luncheon at the Trump
International Hotel.

As you can see here, this proposed order directs the Secretary of Defense to seize
voting machines, quote, effective immediately. But it goes even further than that.
Under the order, President Trump would appoint a special counsel with the power 
to seize machines and then charge people with crimes with all resources necessary
to carry out her duties.

The specific plan was to name Sidney Powell as special counsel. The Trump lawyer
who had spent the post-election period making outlandish claims about Venezuelan
and Chinese interference in the election among others. Here’s what White House Counsel
Pat Cipollone had to say about Sidney Powell’s qualifications to take on such expansive
authority. [Begin Videotape]

PAT CIPOLLONE: I don’t think Sidney — Sidney Powell would say that I thought it 
was a good idea to appoint her special counsel. I was vehemently opposed. I didn’t
think she should have been appointed to anything. [End Videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Sidney Powell told the President that these steps were justified because
of her evidence of foreign interference in the 2020 election.

However, as we’ve seen, Trump’s allies had no such evidence and of course no legal
authority for the federal government to seize state voting machines. Here’s Mr. 
Cipollone again denouncing Sidney Powell’s terrible idea. [Begin Videotape]

PAT CIPOLLONE: There was a real question in my mind and a real concern, you know,
particularly after the Attorney General had reached a conclusion that there wasn’t
sufficient election fraud to change the outcome of the election when other people
kept suggesting that there was. The answer is, what is it? And at some point you
have to put up or shut up. That was my view.

UNKNOWN: Why was this on a broader scale a bad idea for a country?

PAT CIPOLLONE: To have the federal government seize voting machines? That’s a terrible
idea for the country. That’s not how we do things in the United States. There’s 
no legal authority to do that. And there is a way to contest elections. You know,
that — that happens all the time. But the idea that the federal government could
come in and seize election machines, no. That — that’s — I don’t — I don’t understand
why we even have to tell you why that’s a bad idea for the country.

It’s a terrible idea. [End Videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: For all of it’s absurdity, the December 18th meeting was critically
important because President Trump got to watch up close for several hours as his
White House counsel and other White House lawyers destroyed the baseless factual
claims and ridiculous legal arguments being offered by Sidney Powell, Mike Flynn,
and others.

President Trump now knew all of these claims were nonsense, not just from his able
White House lawyers but also from his own Department of Justice officials and indeed
his own campaign officials. As White House counsel Pat Cipollone told us. [Begin
Videotape]

PAT CIPOLLONE: With respect to the whole election fraud issue, it to me is sort 
of if you’re going to make those kind of claims — and people were open to them early
on because people were making all sorts of claims. And the real question is show
the evidence. Ok? [End Videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: It wasn’t just the Justice Department, the Trump campaign, and the
Trump White House lawyers who knew it. Even Rudy Giuliani’s own legal team admitted
that they did not have any real evidence of fraud sufficient to change the election
result. Here’s an e-mail from Rudy Giuliani’s lead investigator, Bernie Kerik.

On December 28th, 2022 to Chief of Staff Mark Meadows. Mr. Kerik did not mince any
words. “We can do all the investigations we want later. But if the President plans
on winning, it’s the legislators that have to be moved and this will do just that.”
Mr. Kerik wanted the President to win. What he didn’t say in this email was what
he would later tell the select committee in a letter that his lawyer wrote to us
in November.

The letter said quote, “It was impossible for Mr. Kerik and his team to determine
conclusively whether there was widespread fraud or whether that widespread fraud
would have altered the outcome of the election.” In other words, even Rudy Giuliani’s
own legal team knew before January 6th that they hadn’t collected enough actual 
evidence to support any of their stolen election claims.

Here’s what Trump campaign senior adviser Jason Miller told the committee about 
some of the so-called evidence of fraud that the campaign had seen from the Giuliani
team. [Begin Videotape]

UNKNOWN: So do you know what the examples of fraud — numbers, names, and supporting
evidence — was that you sent to Mo Brooks’ office. And I say you, I mean you or 
the campaign.

JASON MILLER: There are some very, very general documents as far as — as far as,
say, for example, here are the handful of dead people in several different states.
Here are explanations on a couple of the legal challenges as far as the saying that
the — the rules were changed an unconstitutional manner. But it was — to say that
it was spin is — is probably an understatement. [End Videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Here’s how President Trump’s deputy campaign manager described the
evidence of fraud that the campaign had seen. [Begin Videotape]

UNKNOWN: You never came to learn or understand that Mayor Giuliani had — had produced
evidence of election fraud. Is that fair?

JUSTIN CLARK: That’s fair. [End Videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: And here’s testimony that we received from the speaker of the Arizona
House of Representatives, Rusty Bowers, about an exchange that he had with Rudy 
Giuliani after the election. [Begin Videotape]

ADAM SCHIFF: At some point, did one of them make a comment that they didn’t have
evidence but they had a lot of theories?

RUSTY BOWERS: That was Mr. Giuliani. [End Videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Chief of Staff Mark Meadows told people that he thought Trump should
concede around the time the Electoral College certified the result. But nonetheless
he later worked to try to facilitate President Trump’s wishes. Here’s what Cassidy
Hutchinson told us. [Begin Videotape]

CASSIDY HUTCHINSON: During this period, he — I perceived his goal with all of this
to keep Trump in office. You know, he had very seriously and deeply considered the
allegations of voter fraud. But when he began acknowledging that maybe there wasn’t
enough voter fraud to overturn the election, you know, I — I witnessed him start
to explore potential constitutional loopholes more extensively, which I then connected
with John Eastman’s theories. [End Videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: The startling conclusion is this: even an agreed upon complete lack
of evidence could not stop President Trump, Mark Meadows, and their allies from 
trying to overturn the results of a free and fair election. So let’s return to that
meeting at the White House on the evening of December 18. That night, a group showed
up at the White House including Sidney Powell, retired Lieutenant General Michael
Flynn, and former Overstock.com CEO Patrick Byrne.

After gaining access to the building from a junior White House staffer, the group
made their way to the Oval Office. They were able to speak with the President by
himself for some time until White House officials learned of the meeting. What ensued
was a heated and profane clash between this group and President Trump’s White House
advisors who traded personal insults, accusations of disloyalty to the President,
and even challenges to physically fight.

The meeting would last over six hours, beginning here in the Oval Office, moving
around the West Wing, and many hours later ending up in the President’s private 
residence. The select committee has spoken with six of the participants as well 
as staffers who could hear the screaming from outside the Oval Office. What took
place next is best told in their own words as you will see from this video. [Begin
Videotape]

UNKNOWN: Did you believe that it was going to work, that you were going be able 
to get to see the President without an appointment?

SIDNEY POWELL: I had no idea.

UNKNOWN: In fact you do get to see the President without an appointment.

SIDNEY POWELL: We did.

UNKNOWN: How much time did you have alone with the President? I say alone, you had
other people with you, but, I think from his aides before the crowd came running.

SIDNEY POWELL: Probably no more than 10 or 15 minutes.

UNKNOWN: Was in that —

SIDNEY POWELL: — I bet Pat Cipollone set a new land speed record.

PAT CIPOLLONE: I got a call either for Molly or from Eric Herschmann that I need
to get to the Oval Office.

CASSIDY HUTCHINSON: So that was the first point that I had recognized, Ok, there
is nobody in there from the White House. Mark’s gone. What’s going on right now.

PAT CIPOLLONE: I opened the door and I walked in, I saw General Flynn, I saw Sidney
Powell sitting there. I was not happy to see the people who were in the Oval Office.

UNKNOWN: Explain why.

PAT CIPOLLONE: Well, again, I — I don’t think they were providing — well, first 
of all, the Overstock person I – – I’ve never met — never. I never knew who this
guy was. Actually the first thing I did, I walked in, I looked at him, and I said
who are you? And he told me. I don’t think — I don’t think any of these people were
providing the President with good advice.

And so I — I — I didn’t understand how they had gotten in.

UNKNOWN: In the short period of time that you had with the President, did he seem
receptive to the presentation that you were making?

SIDNEY POWELL: He was very interested in hearing particularly about the CISA findings
and the terms of 13848 that apparently nobody else had bothered to inform him of.

ERIC HERSCHMANN: And I was asking, like, are you’re claiming the Democrats were 
working with Hugo Chavez, Venezuelans, and whomever else. And at one point General
Flynn took out a diagram that supposedly showed IP addresses all over the world.
And — or ISP — who was — who was communicating with whom via the machines and some
comment about like Nest thermostats being hooked up to the Internet.

UNKNOWN: So it’s been reported that during this meeting, Ms. Powell talked about
Dominion voting machines and made various election fraud claims that involve foreign
countries such as Venezuela, Iran, and China. Is that accurate?

MICHAEL FLYNN: The fifth.

UNKNOWN: Was the meeting tense?

DEREK LYONS: Oh yeah. I — it was not a casual meeting.

UNKNOWN: Explain.

DEREK LYONS: I mean, at times there were people shouting at each other, hurling 
insults at each other. It wasn’t just sort of people sitting around on the couch
like chit chatting.

UNKNOWN: Do you recall whether he raised to Ms. Powell the fact that she and the
campaign had lost all of the 60 cases that they had brought in litigation?

PAT CIPOLLONE: Yes. He raised that.

UNKNOWN: And what was the response?

PAT CIPOLLONE: I don’t remember what she said. I don’t think it was a good response.

SIDNEY POWELL: Cipollone and Herschmann and whoever the other guy was showed nothing
but contempt and disdain of the President.

PAT CIPOLLONE: I remember the three of them were really sort of forcefully attacking
me verbally. Eric, Derek, and we were pushing back and we were asking one simple
question as a — as a general matter. Where is the evidence? So.

UNKNOWN: What response did you get when you asked Ms. Powell and her colleagues 
where’s the evidence?

PAT CIPOLLONE: A variety of responses based on my current recollection including,
you know, I can’t believe you would say something, like, you know, things like this.
Like, “What do you mean where’s the evidence? You should know.” Yeah, I — things
like that or, you know, a disregard, I would say, a general disregard for the importance
of actually backing up what you say with facts.

DEREK LYONS: And, you know, then there was discussion of, well, you know, we don’t
have it now but we will have it or whatever.

SIDNEY POWELL: I mean, if — if it had been me sitting in his chair, I would have
fired all of them that night and had em escorted out of the building.

ERIC HERSCHMANN: Which Derek and I both challenged what she was saying. And she 
says, well, the judges are corrupt. And I was like, every one? Every single case
that you’ve done in the country you guys lost, every one of them is corrupt? Even
the ones we appointed? And I’m being nice. I was much more harsh to her.

UNKNOWN: So one of the other things that’s been reported that was said during this
meeting was that President Trump told White House lawyers Mr. Herschmann and Mr.
Cipollone that they weren’t offering him any solutions, but Ms. Powell and others
were. So why not try what Ms. Powell and others were proposing? Do you remember 
anything along those lines being said by President Trump?

DEREK LYONS: I do. That sounds right.

ERIC HERSCHMANN: I think that it got to the point where the screaming was completely,
completely out there. I mean, you got people walk in, it was late at night, had 
been a long day. And what they were proposing I thought was nuts.

RUDY GIULIANI: I’m gonna — I’m gonna categorically describe it as you guys are not
tough enough. Or maybe I put it another way. You’re a bunch of pussies. Excuse the
expression, but that — that’s I — I’m almost certain the word was used.

ERIC HERSCHMANN: Flynn screamed at me that I was a quitter and everything, kept 
on standing up and turning around and screaming at me. And a certain point I had
it with him. So I yelled back better come over. Better sit your effing ass back 
down.

RUDY GIULIANI: The President and the White House team went upstairs to the residence,
but to the public part of the residence. You know, the big — the big parlor where
you can have meetings in the conference room.

UNKNOWN: Yellow oval. They call that the yellow level.

RUDY GIULIANI: Yes, exactly. The yellow oval office. I always called it the upper.
And I’m not exactly sure where the Sidney group went. I think maybe the Roosevelt
Room. And I stayed — In the Cabinet Room, which is kind of cool. I really liked 
that, all my — all by myself.

UNKNOWN: At the end of the day, we landed where we started the meeting, at least
from a structural standpoint, which was Sidney Powell was fighting. Mike Flynn was
fighting. They were looking for avenues that would enable — that would result in
President Trump remaining President Trump for a second term.

JAMIE RASKIN: The meeting finally ended after midnight. Here are text messages sent
by Cassidy Hutchinson during and after the meeting. As you can see, Ms. Hutchinson
reported that the meeting in the West Wing was unhinged. The meeting finally broke
up after midnight. During the early morning of December 19, Cassidy Hutchinson captured
the moment of Mark Meadows escorting Rudy Giuliani off the White House grounds to“
make sure he didn’t wander back into the mansion.” Certain accounts of this meeting
indicate that President Trump actually granted Ms. Powell security clearance and
appointed her to a somewhat ill defined position of special counsel.

SIDNEY POWELL: He asked Pat Cipollone if he had the authority to name a special 
counsel, and he said yes. And then he asked him if he had the authority to give 
me whatever security clearance I needed, and Pat Cipollone said yes. And then the
president said, Ok, you know, I’m the naming her that and I’m giving her security
clearance.

And then shortly before we left and it totally blew up, that’s when Cipollone and/
or Herschmann and whoever the other young man was said you can name her whatever
you want to name her, and no one’s going to pay any attention to it.

UNKNOWN: How did he respond? How did the president respond to that?

SIDNEY POWELL: Something like you see what I deal with. I deal with this all the
time. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Over the ensuing days, no further steps were taken to appoint Sidney
Powell, but there is some ambiguity about what the president actually said and did
during the meeting. Here is how Pat Cipollone described it. [Begin videotape]

PAT CIPOLLONE: I don’t know what her understanding of whether she had been appointed,
what she had been appointed to, Ok? In my view, she hadn’t been appointed to anything
and ultimately wasn’t appointed to anything, because there had to be other steps
taken. And that was my view when I left the meeting. But she may have a different
view, and others may have a different view, and — and the president may have a different
view.

LIZ CHENEY: Were any steps taken, including the president himself telling her she’d
been appointed?

PAT CIPOLLONE: Again, I’m not going to get into what the president said in the meeting.
You know, my recollection is you’re not appointed even — you’re not appointed until—
until steps are taken to get the paperwork done, get — and when I left the meeting,
Ok — I guess — I guess what I’m trying to say is I’m not going to get into what 
the president said or want — said he wanted.

JAMIE RASKIN: Mr. Cipollone, when the matter continued to flare up over the next
several days, was it your understanding that Sidney Powell was still seeking an 
appointment or that she was asserting that she had been appointed by the president
at the December 18 meeting?

PAT CIPOLLONE: You know, now that you mention it, probably both, you know, in — 
in terms of like I think she was — I think she may have been of the view that she
had been appointed and was seeking to, you know, get — get that done, and — and —
and that she should be appointed. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: As you listen to these clips, remember that Ms. Powell, the person
who President Trump tried to make special counsel, was ultimately sanctioned by 
a federal court and sued by Dominion Voting Systems for defamation. In her own defense
to that lawsuit, Sidney Power argued that “no reasonable person would conclude that
the statements were truly statements of fact.” Not long after Sidney Powell, General
Flynn, and Rudy Giuliani — Giuliani left the White House in the early hours of the
morning, President Trump turned away from both his outside advisers’ most outlandish
and unworkable schemes and his White House counsel’s advice to swallow hard and 
accept the reality of his loss.

Instead, Donald Trump issued a tweet that would galvanize his followers, unleash
a political firestorm, and change the course of our history as a country. Trump’s
purpose was to mobilize a crowd. And how do you mobilize a crowd in 2020? With millions
of followers on Twitter, President Trump knew exactly how to do it. At 1:42 AM on
December 19, 2020, shortly after the last participants left the unhinged meeting,
Trump sent out the tweet with his explosive invitation.

Trump repeated his big lie and claimed it was “statistically impossible to have 
lost the 2020 election” before calling for a big protest in DC on January 6th, be
there, will be wild. Trump supporters responded immediately. Women for America First,
a pro-Trump organizing group, had previously applied for a rally permit for January
22nd and 23rd in Washington, DC, several days after Joe Biden was to be inaugurated.

But in the hours after the tweet, they moved their permit to January 6th, two weeks
before. This rescheduling created the rally where Trump would eventually speak. 
The next day, Ali Alexander, leader of the Stop the Steal organization and a key
mobilizer of Trump supporters, registered Wildprotest.com, named after Trump’s tweet.

Wildprotest.com provided comprehensive information about numerous newly organized
protest events in Washington. It included event times, places, speakers, and details
on transportation to Washington DC. Meanwhile, other key Trump supporters, including
far right media personalities, began promoting the wild protest on January 6th. [
Begin videotape]

ALEX JONES: It’s Saturday, December 19th. The year is 2020, and one of the most 
historic events in American history has just taken place. President Trump, in the
early morning hours today, tweeted that he wants the American people to march on
Washington DC on January 6th, 2021.

TIM POOL: And now Donald Trump is calling on his supporters to descend on Washington
DC January 6th.

ALEX JONES: He is now calling on we the People to take action and to show our numbers.

MATT BRACKEN: We’re going to only be saved by millions of Americans moving to Washington,
occupying the entire area, if — if necessary storming right into the Capitol. You
know, they’re — we know the rules of engagement. If you have enough people, you 
can push down any kind of a fence or a wall.

TIM POOL: This could be Trump’s last stand. And it’s a time when he has specifically
called on his supporters to arrive in DC. That’s something that may actually be 
the big push Trump supporters need to say this is it. It’s now or never.

SALTY CRACKER: Ya better understand something, son. Ya better understand something.
Red wave, bitch. Red wed — there’s gonna be a red wedding going down January 6th.

TIM POOL: On that day, Trump says show up for a protest. It’s gonna be wild. And
based on what we’ve already seen from the previous events, I think Trump is absolutely
correct.

SALTY CRACKER: Motherfucker, you better look outside. You better look out January
6th. Kick that fucking door open, look down the street. There’re gonna be a million
plus geeked up armed Americans.

ALEX JONES: The time for games is over. The time for action is now. Where were you
when history called? Where were you when you and your children’s destiny and future
was on the line? [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: In that clip, you heard one of Trump’s supporters predict a red wedding,
which is a pop culture reference to mass slaughter. But the point is that Trump’s
call to Washington reverberated powerfully and pervasively online. The committee
has interviewed a former Twitter employee, who explained the effect that Trump had
on the Twitter platform.

This employee was on the team responsible for platform and content moderation policies
on Twitter throughout 2020 and 2021. The employee testified that Twitter considered
adopting a stricter content moderation policy after President Trump told the Proud
Boys to stand back and stand by from the lectern at the September 29th presidential
debate, but Twitter chose not to act.

Here’s the former employee, whose voice has been obscured to protect their identity,
discussing Trump’s stand back and stand by comment and the effect it had. [Begin
videotape]

UNKNOWN: My concern was that the former president, for seemingly the first time,
was speaking directly to extremist organizations and giving them directives. We 
had not seen that sort of direct communication before, and that concerned me. So,
just to clarify further, you were worried, others at Twitter were worried, that 
the president might use your platform to speak directly to folks who might be incited
to violence?

Yes. I believe that Twitter relished in the knowledge that they were also the favorite
and most used service of the former president, and enjoyed having that sort of power
within the social media ecosystem. If President Trump were anyone else, would it
have taken until January 2021 for him to be suspended?

Absolutely not. If Donald — if former President Donald Trump were any other user
on Twitter, he would have been permanently suspended a very long time ago. [End 
videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Despite these grave concerns, Trump remained on the platform completely
unchecked. Then came the December 19 tweet, and everything it inspired. Indeed —[
Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: It was — it felt as if — if a mob was being organized, and they were gathering
together their weaponry and their logic and their reasoning behind why they were
prepared to fight. Prior to December 19th, again, it was — it was vague. It was —
it was nonspecific but very clear that individuals were ready, willing, and able
to take up arms.

After this tweet on December 19th, again, it became clear not only were these individuals
ready and willing, but the leader of their cause was asking them to join him in 
this cause and in fighting for this cause in DC on January 6th as well. I will also
say what shocked me was the responses to these tweets, right?

So, these were — a lot of the locked and loaded, stand back, stand by, those tweets
were in response to Donald Trump saying things like this, right? So, there would
be a response that said big protest in DC on January 6th, be there, be wild, and
someone would respond and say I’m locked and loaded and ready for civil war part
two, right?

I very much believe that Donald Trump posting this tweet on December 19th was essentially
staking flag in DC on January 6th for his supporters to come and rally. And you 
were concerned about the potential for this gathering becoming violent? Absolutely.[
End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Indeed, many of Trump’s followers took to social media to declare 
that they were ready to answer Trump’s call. One user asked is the 6th D-Day? Is
that why Trump wants everyone there? Another asserted Trump just told us all to 
come armed. Fucking A, this is happening. A third took it even further. It will 
be wild means we need volunteers for the firing squad.

Jim Watkins, the owner of 8kun, the fringe online forum that was birthplace of the
QAnon extremist movement, confirmed the importance of Trump’s tweet. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: Why did you first decide to go to DC for January 6th?

JIM WATKINS: When — when the president of the United States announced that he was
going to have a rally, then I bought ticket went. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Watkins was at the Capitol on January 6th. Some who have since been
indicted for their involvement in the attack on the Capitol also responded. One 
of them posted on the 19th, “Calling all patriots. Be in Washington DC January the
6th. This wasn’t organized by any group. DJT has invited us, and it’s going to be
wild.” Some of the online rhetoric turned openly homicidal and white nationalist,
such as why don’t we just kill them, every last Democrat, down to the last man, 
woman, and child, and it’s time for the day of the rope.

White revolution is the only solution. Others realized that police would be standing
in the way of their effort to overturn the election, so one wrote I’m ready to die
for my beliefs. Are you ready to die, police? Another wrote on thedonald.win, cops
don’t have standing if they’re laying on the ground in a pool of their own blood.

Thedonald.win was an openly racist and anti-Semitic forum. The Select Committee 
deposed that site’s founder, Jody Williams. He confirmed how the president’s tweet
created a laser like focus on the date of January the 6th. [Begin videotape]

JODY WILLIAMS: And people had been talking about going to DC since the election 
was over.

UNKNOWN: And do you recall whether or not the conversation around those dates centered
on the 6th after the president’s tweet?

JODY WILLIAMS: Oh, sure. Yeah. I mean after it was announced that, you know, he 
was going to be there on the 6th to talk, yes. Then — then anything else was kind
of shut out and it was just gonna on the sixth.

UNKNOWN: Ok. And that was pretty clearly reflected in the — the content on — on 
the site?

JODY WILLIAMS: Yeah. Yeah, sure. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: On that site, many shared plans and violent threats. Bring handcuffs
and wait near the tunnels, wrote one user. A commenter replied suggesting zip ties
instead. One post encouraged others to come with body armor, knuckles, shields, 
bats, pepper spray, whatever it takes. All of those were used on the 6th. The post
concluded, join your local Proud Boys chapter as well.

Thedonald.win featured discussions of the tunnels beneath the Capitol complex, suggestions
for targeting members of Congress, and encouragement to attend this once in a lifetime
event. While Trump supporters grew more aggressive online, he continued to rile 
up his base on Twitter. He said there was overwhelming evidence that the election
was the biggest scam in our nation’s history.

As you can see, the president continued to boost the event, tweeting about it more
than a dozen times in the lead up to January the 6th. Mr. Chairman, I reserve.

BENNIE THOMPSON: The chair requests that those in a hearing room remain seated until
the Capitol Police have escorted members from the room. Pursuant to the order of
the committee of today, the chair declares the committee in recess for a period 
of approximately 10 minutes. Committee will be in order. Chair recognizes gentleman
from Maryland, Mr. Raskin.

JAMIE RASKIN: Mr. Chairman, President Trump’s tweet drew tens of thousands of Americans
to Washington to form the angry crowd that would be transformed on January the sixth
into a violent mob. Dr. Donell Harvin, who is the chief of Homeland Security and
intelligence for DC, told the committee how his team saw Trump’s December 19th tweet
unite violent groups across the spectrum on the far right.

[Begin Videotape]

DONELL HARVIN: We — we got derogatory information from OSINT suggesting that some
very, very violent individuals were organizing to come to DC, and not only were 
they organized to come to DC, but they were — these groups, these nonaligned groups
were aligning. And so the rent – – all the red flags went up at that point.

You know, when you have armed militia collaborating with white supremacy groups 
collaborating with conspiracy theory groups online all toward a common goal, you
start seeing what we call in, you know, terrorism, a blended ideology. And that’s
a very, very bad sign. Then when they were clearly across — not just across one 
platform, but across multiple platforms of these groups coordinating, not just like
chatting, hey, how’s it going?

You know what’s the weather like where you’re at? But like, what are you bringing?
What are you wearing? You know, where — where — where do we meet up? Do you have
plans for the Capitol? That operational — that’s like pre operational intelligence,
right? And that — that is something that’s clearly alarming.

[End Videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: The Proud Boys and the Oath Keepers are two key groups that responded
immediately to President Trump’s call. The Proud Boys are a far right street fighting
group that glorifies violence and white supremacy. The Oath Keepers are extremists
who promote a wide range of conspiracy theories and sought to act as a private paramilitary
force for Donald Trump.

The Department of Justice has charged leaders of both groups with seditious conspiracy
to overthrow the government of the United States on January the sixth. Trump’s December
19th tweet motivated these two extremist groups, which have historically not worked
together to coordinate their activities. On December 19th at 10:22 a.m., just hours
after President Trump’s tweet, Kelly Meggs, the head of the Florida Oath Keepers,
declared an alliance among the Oath Keepers, the Proud Boys and the Florida Three
Percenters, another militia group.

He wrote, we have decided to work together and shut this shit down. Phone records
obtained by the Select Committee show that later that afternoon, Mr. Meggs called
Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio, and they spoke for several minutes. The very next
day, the Proud Boys got to work. The Proud Boys launched an encrypted chat called
the Ministry of Self-defense.

The committee obtained hundreds of these messages, which show strategic and tactical
planning about January the 6th, including maps of Washington, DC that pinpoint the
location of police. In the weeks leading up to the attack, leaders in both the Proud
Boys and the Oath Keepers worked with Trump allies. One such ally was Lieutenant
General Michael Flynn, Trump’s former national security advisor and one of the participants
in the unhinged meeting at the White House on December 18th. He also had connections
to the Oath Keepers.

This photo from December 12th shows Flynn and Patrick Byrne, another Trump ally,
who was present at that December 18th meeting guarded by indicted Oath Keeper Roberto
Minuta. Another view of the scene shows Oath Keepers leader Stewart Rhodes in the
picture as well. Another central figure with ties to this network of extremist groups
was Roger Stone, a political consultant and longtime confidant of President Trump.

He pardoned both Flynn and Stone in the weeks between the election on November 3rd
and January 6th. In the same time frame, Stone communicated with both the Proud 
Boys

and the Oath Keepers regularly. The committee obtained encrypted content from a 
group – – from a group chat called Friends of Stone, FOS, which included Stone, 
Rhodes, Tarrio and Ali Alexander.

The chat focused on various pro-Trump events in November and December of 2020, as
well as January 6th. As you can see here, Stewart Rhodes himself urged the Friends
of Stone to have people go to their state capitols if they could not make it to 
Washington for the first million MAGA March on November 14th. These friends of Roger
Stone had a significant presence at multiple pro-Trump events after the election,
including in Washington on December the 12th. On that day, Stewart Rhodes called
for Donald Trump to invoke martial law, promising bloodshed if he did not.

[Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: We need to know from you that you are with him, that he does not do it 
now while he is commander in chief, we’re going to have to do it ourselves later
in a much more desperate, much more bloody war. Let’s get it on now while he is 
still the commander in chief. Hooah. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: That night, the Proud Boys engaged in violence on the streets of Washington
and hurled aggressive insults at the police. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: You oath breakers, do your fucking job. Give us one hour, one hour. [End
videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Just the previous night, the co-host of Infowars issued an ominous
warning at a rally alongside Roger Stone and Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio. [
Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: [Inaudible] We will be back in January. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Encrypted chats obtained by the Select Committee show that Kelly Meggs,
the indicted leader of the Florida Oath Keepers, spoke directly with Roger Stone
about security on January 5th and 6th. In fact, on January 6th, Stone was guarded
by two Oath Keepers who have since been criminally indicted for seditious conspiracy.

One of them later pleaded guilty and, according to the Department of Justice, admitted
that the Oath Keepers were ready to use, quote, lethal force if necessary against
anyone who tried to remove President Trump from the White House, including the National
Guard. As we’ve seen, the Proud Boys were also part of the Friends of Stone Network.

Stone’s ties to the Proud Boys go back many years. He’s even taken their so-called
fraternity creed required for the first level of initiation to the group. [Begin
videotape]

ROGER STONE: Hi, I’m Roger Stone. I’m a Western chauvinist, and I refuse to apologize
for creating the modern world.

UNKNOWN: Thank you, Roger. [End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: Kelly Sorrell, a lawyer who assists the Oath Keepers and a volunteer
lawyer for the Trump campaign, explained to the committee how Roger Stone and other
figures brought extremists of different stripes and views together. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: You mentioned that Mr. Stone wanted to start the Stop the Steal series 
of rallies. Who did you consider the leader of these rallies? It sounds like from
what you just said, it was Mr. Stone, Mr. Jones, and Mr. Ali Alexander. Is that 
correct?

KELLY SORRELL: Those are the ones that became like the — the center point for everything.[
End videotape]

JAMIE RASKIN: We’ll learn more from Ms. Murphy about these individuals and their
involvement in the days leading up to the violent attack on January 6th. We’ll also
hear how they were allowed to speak at a rally for President Trump the night before
January 6th, even though organizers had expressed serious concerns about their violent
and extremist rhetoric directly to Mark Meadows.

And you’ll hear testimony from White House aides who were with the President as 
he watched the crowd from the Oval Office, and will testify about how excited he
was for the following day. Let me note now that our investigation continues on these
critical issues. We have only shown a small fraction of what we have found.

I look forward to the public release of more of our findings later, Mr. Chairman,
and I now yield back.

BENNIE THOMPSON: The gentleman yields back. The Chair recognizes the gentlewoman
from Florida, Ms. Murphy.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: During our most recent hearing, the committee showed some evidence
of what President Trump, Chief of Staff Mark Meadows, and other White House officials
knew about the potential for violence on January 6th. And despite this information,
they made no effort to cancel the rally, halt the march to the Capitol, or even 
to lower the temperature among President Trump’s supporters.

Katrina Pierson, one of the organizers of January 6th rally and a former campaign
spokeswoman for President Trump, grew increasingly apprehensive after learning that
multiple activists had been proposed as speakers for the January 6th rally. These
included some of the people we discussed earlier in this hearing.

Roger Stone, a longtime outside advisor to President Trump; Alex Jones, the founder
of the conspiracy theory website Infowars; and Ali Alexander, an activist known 
for his violent political rhetoric. On December 30th, Miss Pierson exchanged text
messages with another key rally organizer about why people like Mr. Alexander and
Mr. Jones were being suggested as speakers at the President’s rally on January 6th.
Ms. Pierson’s explanation was POTUS, and she remarks that the President likes the
crazies.

The committee asked Ms. Pierson about these messages and this is what she said. [
Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: So when you said that he likes the crazies, were you talking about President
Trump?

KATRINA PIERSON: Yes, I was talking about President Trump. He loved people who viciously
defended him in public.

UNKNOWN: But consistent, in terms of the support for these people, at least with
what the President likes from what you could tell.

KATRINA PIERSON: Yes, these are people that would be very, very vicious in publicly
defending him. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: On January 2nd, Ms. Pierson’s concerns about the potential rally
speakers had grown serious enough that she reached out to Mr. Meadows directly. 
She wrote, Good afternoon. Would you mind giving me a call regarding this January
6 event? Things have gotten crazy and I desperately need some direction, please.

Please According to phone records obtained by the committee. Ms. Pierson received
a phone call from Mr. Meadows 8 minutes later. Here is what Ms. Pierson said about
that conversation. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: So what specifically did you tell them, though, about other — other events?

KATRINA PIERSON: Just that there were a bunch of entities coming in. Some were very
suspect, but they’re going to be on other — on other stages, some on other days.
A very, very brief overview of what was actually happening and why I raised the 
red flags.

UNKNOWN: And when you told him that people were very suspect, what — what — did 
you tell him what you meant by that? Or what did you convey to him about what — 
the problems with these folks?

KATRINA PIERSON: I think I even texted him some of my concerns, but I did briefly
go over some of the concerns that I had raised to everybody with Alex Jones or Ali
Alexander and some of the rhetoric that they were doing. I probably mentioned to
him that they had already caused trouble at other capitols — or at the previous 
event, the previous march that they did for protesting.

And I just had a concern about it. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Ms. Pierson was especially concerned about Ali Alexander and Alex
Jones, because in November 2020, both men and some of their supporters had entered
the Georgia State Capitol to protest the results of the 2020 election. Ms. Pierson
believed that she mentioned this to Mark Meadows on this January 2nd call.

Notably, January 2nd is the same day on which, according to Cassidy Hutchinson. 
Ms. Meadows — Mr. Meadows warned her of things — that things might get real, real
bad on January 6. After her January 2nd call with Mr. Meadows, Katrina Pierson sent
an email to fellow rally organizers. She wrote, POTUS expectations are to have something
intimate at the Ellipse, and call on everyone to march to the Capitol.

The President’s own documents suggest that the President had decided to call on 
his supporters to go to the Capitol on January 6, but that he chose not to widely
announce it until his speech on the Ellipse that morning. The committee has obtained
this draft, updated — undated tweet from the National Archives.

It includes a stamp stating, President has seen. The draft tweet reads: I will be
making a big speech at 10 a.m. on January 6 at the Ellipse south of the White House.
Please arrive early. Massive crowds expected. March to the Capitol after. Stop the
steal. Although this tweet was never sent, rally organizers were discussing and 
preparing for the march to the Capitol in the days leading up to January 6. This
is a January 4th text message from a rally organizer to Mike Lindell, the MyPillow
CEO. The organizer says, you know, this stays between us. We’re having a second 
stage at the Supreme Court again, after the Ellipse.

POTUS is going to have us march there/the Capitol. It cannot get out about the second
stage, because people will try and set up another and sabotage it. It can also not
get out about the march, because I will be in trouble with the National Park Service
and all the agencies. But POTUS is going to just call for it, quote, unexpectedly.

The end of the message indicates that the President’s plan to have his followers
march to the Capitol was not being broadly discussed. And then on the morning of
January 5th, Ali Alexander, whose firebrand style concerned Katrina Pierson, sent
a similar text to a conservative journalist. Mr. Alexander said, Tomorrow: Ellipse,
then US Capitol.

Trump is supposed to order us to the Capitol at the end of his speech, but we will
see. President Trump did follow through on his plan using his January 6th speech
to tell his supporters to march to the Capitol on January 6. The evidence confirms
that this was not a spontaneous call to action, but rather was a deliberate strategy
decided upon in advance by the President.

Another part of the President’s strategy involves certain members of Congress who
amplified his unsupported assertions that the election had been stolen. In the weeks
after the election, the White House coordinated closely with President Trump’s allies
in Congress to disseminate his false claims and to encourage members of the public
to fight the outcome on January 6. We know that the President met with various members
to discuss January 6 well before the joint session.

The President’s private schedule for December 21, 2020, shows a private meeting 
with Republican members of Congress. We know that Vice President Pence, Chief of
Staff Mark Meadows, and Rudy Giuliani also attended that meeting. We obtained an
email that was sent from Congressman Mo Brooks of Alabama to Mark Meadows, setting
up that meeting.

The subject line is: White House meeting December 21st regarding January 6. In his
email, Congressman Brooks explained that he had not asked anyone to join him in 
the, quote, January 6 effort because in his view, quote, only citizens can exert
the necessary influence on Senators and Congressmen to join this fight against massive
voter fraud and election theft. At this point, you may also recall testimony given
in our earlier hearing by Acting Attorney General Richard Donoghue who said that
the President asked the Department of Justice to, quote, just say that the election
was corrupt and leave the rest to me and the Republican Congressman. According to
White House visitor logs obtained by the committee, members of Congress present 
at the White House on December 21st included Congressman Brian Babin, Andy Biggs,
Matt Gaetz, Louie Gohmert, Paul Gosar, Andy Harris, Jody Hice, Jim Jordan, and Scott
Perry.

Then Congresswoman-elect Marjorie Taylor Greene was also there. We heard testimony
in an earlier hearing that a pardon was ultimately requested by Congressman Mo Brooks
and other members of Congress Congress who attended this meeting. We’ve asked witnesses
what happened during the December 21st meeting, and we’ve learned that part of the
discussion centered on the role of the vice president during the counting of the
electoral votes.

These members of Congress were discussing what would later be known as the Eastman
theory, which was being pushed by attorney John Eastman. In one of our earlier hearings,
you heard in great detail that President Trump was trying to convince Vice President
Pence to do something illegal. His White House counsel confirmed all of that in 
testimony last week. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: Your view, Mr. Cipollone, upon that — those discussions with Mr. Philbin,
with Greg Jacobs, what was your assessment as to what the vice president could or
could not do in the general session?

PAT CIPOLLONE: What was my assessment about what he could or couldn’t do?

UNKNOWN: Yes, your view of the issues?

PAT CIPOLLONE: My view was that a vice president had — didn’t have the legal authority
to do anything except what he did.

UNKNOWN: They’ve both told us, Mr. Philbin and Mr. Jacob, that they looked very 
closely at the Eastman memos, the Eastman theory, and thought that it had no basis,
that it was not a strategy that the president should pursue. It sounds like that’s
consistent with your impression as well.

PAT CIPOLLONE: My impression would have been informed, certainly, by them. [End 
videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Campaign senior adviser Jason Miller told us that Mr. Cipollone
thought John Eastman’s theories were nutty, something Mr. Cipollone wouldn’t refute.[
Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: We’ve received testimony from various people about this. One was Jason 
Miller, who was a campaign — said that the way it was communicated to me was that
Pat Cipollone thought the idea was nutty, and at one point confronted Eastman, basically
with the same sentiment, that —

PAT CIPOLLONE: I don’t have a reason to contradict what he said. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: On January 4th, John Eastman went to the White House to meet with
the president and vice president. Mr. Cipollone tried to participate in this meeting,
but he was apparently turned away. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: You didn’t go to the meeting in the Oval Office where Eastman met with 
the president and the vice president. Do you know — do you remember why you didn’t
personally attend?

PAT CIPOLLONE: I did walk to that meeting and I did go into the Oval Office with
the idea of attending that meeting. And then I ultimately did not attend that meeting.

UNKNOWN: Why not?

PAT CIPOLLONE: The reasons for that are privileged.

UNKNOWN: Ok. Were you asked to not attend the meeting, or did you make a personal
decision not to attend the meeting?

PAT CIPOLLONE: Again, without getting into —

UNKNOWN: Privilege. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Recall that Greg Jacob, the vice president’s counsel, stated that
Mr. Eastman acknowledged he would lose 9 to 0 if his legal theory were challenged
in the Supreme Court. Mr. Cipollone had reviewed Mr. Eastman’s legal theory and 
expressed his view repeatedly that the vice president was right. He even offered
to take the blame for the vice president’s position. [Begin videotape]

PAT CIPOLLONE: I thought that the vice president did not have the authority to do
what was being suggested under a proper reading of the law. I conveyed that.

UNKNOWN: Ok.

PAT CIPOLLONE: I think I actually — somebody, you know, in the vice president’s —
just blame me. This — you know, this is — I’m not a politician. You know, I don’t—
but, you know, I just said I’m a lawyer. This is my legal opinion. I — but let me
tell you this. Can I say a word about the vice president, please? I think the vice
president did the right thing.

I think he did the courageous thing. I have a great deal of respect for Vice President
Pence. I’ve worked with him very closely. I think he understood my opinion. I think
he understood my opinion afterwards as well. I think he did a great service to this
country. And I think I suggested to somebody that he should be get — given the Presidential
Medal of Freedom for — for his actions.

[End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Earlier this year, a federal district — district court judge concluded
that President Trump and Mr. Eastman, relying on Mr. Eastman’s theory, more likely
than not violated multiple federal criminal laws in their pressure campaign against
the vice president. Also, recall earlier in this hearing we saw that Rudy Giuliani’s
team did not have actual evidence of fraud sufficient to change the result of the
election.

That’s important because, as January 6th approached, the Republican members of the
House and Senate were looking for reason to object to the electors, and no real 
evidence was ever given to them. And we know that Republican members of the House
received a memorandum from the chairwoman of the House Republican Caucus in the 
days before January 6th explaining in detail the many constitutional and legal problems
with objections and describing the principal judicial rulings dismissing the claims
of widespread fraud.

But their plan to object to the certification of the election on January 6th went
forward anyway. The next day, on January 5th, the day before the attack on the Capitol,
tens of thousands of people converged on Washington. While certain close associates
of President Trump privately expressed concerns about what would occur on January
6th, other members of the president’s inner circle spoke with great anticipation
about the events to come.

The committee has learned from the White House phone logs that the president spoke
to Steve Bannon, his close adviser, at least twice on January 5th. The first conversation
they had lasted for 11 minutes. Listen to what Mr. Bannon said that day after the
first call he had with the President. [Begin videotape]

STEVE BANNON: All hell is going to break loose tomorrow. It’s all converging and
now we’re on, as they say, the point of attack, right, the point of attack tomorrow.
I’ll tell you this, it’s not going to happen like you think it’s going to happen,
Ok? It’s going to be quite extraordinarily different. And all I can say is strap
in. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: From those same phone logs, we know that the president and Mr.
Bannon spoke again on the phone that evening, this time for six minutes. That same
day, on the eve of January 6th, supporters of President Trump gathered in Washington,
DC at another rally. This rally was held at Freedom Plaza, which is located near
the White House and featured some of the speakers who Katrina Pierson and others
deemed too extreme to share the stage with the president the next morning.

And as this rally was underway, the president asked members of his staff to come
to the Oval Office. Let’s hear from the White House aides who were in the Oval Office
that night. [Begin videotape]

NICHOLAS LUNA: I was in the office — in the Oval Office, and he had asked me to 
open the door so that he could hear. I guess there was a concert or a — or something
going on.

UNKNOWN: Did he say anything other than just open the door?

NICHOLAS LUNA: He — he made a comment. I don’t remember specifically what he said,
but there is a lot of energy.

SARAH MATTHEWS: We walked in, the staff was kind of standing up and assembled along
the wall, and the president was at the desk and Dan Scavino was on the couch. And
the president was dictating a tweet that he wanted Scavino to send out. Then the
president started talking about the rally the next day. He had the door of the Oval
open to the Rose Garden because you could hear the crowd already assembled outside
on the Ellipse.

And they were playing music, and it was so loud that you could feel it shaking in
the Oval. He was in a very good mood. And I say that because he had not been in 
a good mood for weeks leading up to that, and then it seemed like he was in a fantastic
mood that evening.

JUDD DEERE: He asked if — if members of Congress would be with him tomorrow.

UNKNOWN: And what did you understand by — meaning voting in his favor as opposed
to physically with him or anything like that?

JUDD DEERE: Yeah, I took that to mean not voting to certify the election.

SARAH MATTHEWS: Then he did look to the staff and ask for ideas of how — if I recall,
he said that we could make the RINOs do the right thing is the way he phrased it.
And no one spoke up initially, because I think everyone was trying to process what
that — he meant by that.

SHEALAH CRAIGHEAD: The president was making notes that — talking then about we should
go up to the Capitol, what’s the best route to go to the Capitol.

JUDD DEERE: I said he should focus on policy accomplishments. I didn’t mention 2020.

UNKNOWN: What was his response?

JUDD DEERE: He acknowledged that and said we’ve had a lot, something along those
lines. And — but then he fairly quickly move to how fired up the crowd is, was going
to be.

UNKNOWN: And what did he say about it?

JUDD DEERE: Just that they were — they were fired up. They were angry. They feel
like the election’s been stolen, the election was rigged.

UNKNOWN: Did he give you any indication of how he knew that the crowd was fired 
up or angry?

JUDD DEERE: He continued to reference being able to hear them outside. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Through the open door of the Oval Office, the president could 
hear the sound of the crowd and the music at the rally at the Freedom Plaza. And
these are some of the things that they were saying there at the plaza, just blocks
from where the president sat that evening excited for the next day. [Begin videotape]

ROGER STONE: This is nothing less than an epic struggle for the future of this country,
between dark and light, between the Godly and the godless, between good and evil.
And we will win this fight or America would step off into a thousand years of darkness.

MICHAEL FLYNN: Tomorrow, tomorrow, trust me, the American people that are standing
on the soil that we are standing on tonight, and they’re going to be standing on
this soil tomorrow, this is soil that we have fought over, fought for, and we will
fight for in the future. The members — the members of Congress, the members of the
House of Representatives, the members of the — of the United States Senate, those
of — those of you who are feeling weak tonight, those of you that don’t have the
moral fiber in your body, get some tonight because tomorrow we the people are going
to be here.

And we want you to know that we will not stand for a lie. We will not stand for 
a lie.

ALI ALEXANDER: I want them to know that 1776 is always an option. [Cheering] These
degenerates in the deep state are going to give us what we want or we are going 
to shut this country down. [Cheering]

ALEX JONES: It’s 1776, 1776, 1776, 1776. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: At 5:05 PM, as the Freedom Plaza rally was underway just blocks
away, President Trump tweeted, Washington is being inundated with people who don’t
want to see an election victory stolen by emboldened radical left Democrats. Our
country has had enough. They won’t take it anymore. To the crowds gathering in DC
he added, we hear you and love you from the Oval Office.

The committee has learned that on January 5th, there were serious concerns at Twitter
about the anticipated violence the next day. Listen to what the Twitter witness 
told us about their desperate efforts to get Twitter to do something. [Begin videotape]

UNKNOWN: What was your — your gut feeling on the night of January 5th? I believe
I sent a Slack message to someone that said something along the lines of when people
are shooting each other tomorrow, I will try and rest in the knowledge that we tried.
And so, I went to — I don’t know that I slept that night, to be honest with you.
I — I was on pins and needles because, again, for — for months I had been begging
and anticipating and attempting to raise the reality that if nothing — if we made
no intervention into what I saw occurring, people were going to die. And on January
5th, I realized no intervention was coming. No — there — and even as — as hard as
I had tried to create one or implement one, there was nothing and we were — we were
at the whims and the mercy of a violent crowd that was locked and loaded.

And just for the record, this was content that was echoing statements by the former
president, but also Proud Boys and other known violent extremist groups? Yeah. [
End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: There were also concerns among members of Congress. We have a 
recently released recording of a conversation that took place among Republican members
in the US Capitol on the eve of January 6th. This is Republican Congresswoman Debbie
Lesko from Arizona, who led some of the unfounded objections to the election results.[
Begin videotape]

DEBBIE LESKO: I also asked leadership to come up with a safety plan for members.
I’m actually very concerned about this, because we have who knows how many hundreds
of thousands of people coming here. We have Antifa. We also have, quite honestly,
Trump supporters who actually believe that we are going to overturn the election.

And when that doesn’t happen, most likely will not happen, they are going to go 
nuts. [End videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: That same evening, as President Trump listened to the rally from
the Oval Office, he was also working on his speech to be delivered the next day.
And based on documents we’ve received from the National Archives, including multiple
drafts of the President’s speech as well as from witness testimony, we understand
how that speech devolved into a call to action and a call to fight.

One of the first edits President Trump made to his speech was to incorporate his
5:05 pm tweet, revising his speech to say, “all of us are here today, do not want
to see our election victory stolen by emboldened radical left Democrats. Our country
has had enough. We will not take it anymore.” He also added, “together we will stop
the steal”. President Trump’s edits continued into the morning of January 6th. And
as you can see from the President’s daily diary here, the President spoke to his
chief speechwriter, Stephen Miller, for over 25 minutes that morning.

Following his call with Mr. Miller, President Trump inserted for the first time 
a line in his speech that said, quote, “and we will see whether Mike Pence enters
history as a truly great and courageous leader. All he has to do is refer the illegally
submitted electoral votes back to the states that were given false and fraudulent
information where they want to recertify”. No prior version of this speech had referenced
Vice President Pence or his role during the joint session on January 6th. These 
last minute edits by President Trump to his speech were part of the President’s 
pressure campaign against his own Vice President.

But not everyone wanted these lines regarding the Vice President included in the
President’s speech, including White House lawyer, Eric Hirschmann. [Begin Videotape]

UNKNOWN: Did you ever speak to anybody in the White House at the time about this
disagreement between the President and the Vice President other than the President
based on the objection from your counsel?

STEPHEN MILLER: Maybe had a brief conversation about it with Eric Hirschmann.

UNKNOWN: Tell me about that. What do you remember him saying to you about this disagreement?

STEPHEN MILLER: I just remember him saying that — that he had a — don’t — get this
wrong — sort of something to the effect of thinking that it would be counterproductive
I think he thought to — to discuss the matter publicly.

UNKNOWN: So it came up in the context of editing the President’s speech on January
the sixth.

STEPHEN MILLER: I just came up in the conversation where Eric knew what was in the
speech and so he had a sidebar with me about it. [End Videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: And so the speechwriters took that advice and removed the lines
about Vice President Pence. And later that morning at 11:20 am President Trump had
a phone call with the Vice President. And as the committee detailed in an earlier
hearing, that phone call was by all accounts tense and heated. During this call,
the Vice President told the President that he would not attempt to change the outcome
of the election.

In response, the President called the Vice President of the United States a wimp
and other derogatory words. As you can see in this email, after Vice President Pence
told President Trump that he would not unilaterally deliver him a second term in
office, the speechwriters were directed to re-insert the Mike Pence lines.

Here is how one of the speechwriters described President Trump’s last minute change
to the speech. [Begin Videotape]

VINCENT HALEY: And as I recall, there was a very tough — a tough sentence about 
the Vice President that was — that was — was added. [End Videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: President Trump wanted to use his speech to attack Vice President
Pence in front of a crowd of thousands of angry supporters who had been led to believe
the election was stolen. When President Trump arrived at the Ellipse to deliver 
his speech, he was still worked up from his call with Vice President Pence.

And although Ivanka Trump would not say so, her chief of staff gave the committee
some insight into the President’s frustration. [Begin Videotape]

UNKNOWN: It’s been reported that you ultimately decided to attend the rally because
you hoped that you would calm the President and keep the event on an even keel. 
Is that accurate?

IVANKA TRUMP: No, I don’t know who said that or where that came from.

UNKNOWN: What did she share with you about why it was concerning that her father
was upset or agitated after that call with Vice President Pence in relation to the
Ellipse rally? Why did that matter? Why did he have to be calmed down, I should 
say.

JULIE RADFORD: Well, she shared that he had called the Vice President a not — an[
expletive] word, I think that bothered her. And I think she could tell based on 
the conversations and what was going on in the office that he was angry and upset
and people were providing this information. And she felt like she might be able 
to help calm the situation down at least before he went on to stage.

[End Videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: The President did go on stage and then he gave the speech that
he wanted to give. It included the formal changes he had requested the night before
and in that morning. But also many important last minute adlib changes. A single
scripted reference in the speech to Mike Pence became eight. A single scripted reference
to rally goers marching to the Capitol became four.

With President Trump adlibbing that he would be joining the protesters at the Capitol.
Added throughout his speech were references to fighting and the need for people 
to have courage and to be strong. The word peacefully was in the staff written script
and used only once. Here are some of these adlib changes that the President made
to his speech.

[Begin Videotape]

DONALD TRUMP: Because you’ll never take back our country with weakness. You have
to show strength and you have to be strong. So I hope Mike has the courage to do
what he has to do. And I hope he doesn’t listen to the rhinos and the stupid people
that he’s listening to. We fight like hell. And if you don’t fight like hell, you’re
not going to have a country anymore.

But we’re going to try and give our Republicans, the weak ones, because the strong
ones don’t need any of our help, we’re going to try and give them the kind of pride
and boldness that they need to take back our country. So let’s walk down Pennsylvania
Avenue — [End Videotape]

STEPHANIE MURPHY: White House counsel, Pat Cipollone, and his deputy did not attend
the speech and they were concerned that the statements in the speech about the election
were false. In fact, the

message that President Trump delivered that day was built on a foundation of lies.
He lied to his supporters that the election was stolen.

He stoked their anger. He called for them to fight for him. He directed them to 
the US Capitol. He told them he would join them, and his supporters believed him
and many headed towards the Capitol. As a result, people died. People were injured.
Many of his supporters’ lives will never be the same. President Trump’s former campaign
manager, Brad Parscale, recognized the impact of the speech immediately and this
is what he said on January 6th in excerpts from text messages to Katrina Pierson.

Mr. Parscale said, quote, “this is about Trump pushing for uncertainty in our country”.“
A sitting President asking for civil war.” And then when he said, “this week I feel
guilty for helping him win”. Katrina Pierson responded, “you did what you felt right
at the time and therefore it was right”. Mr. Parscale added, “yeah, but a woman 
is dead”. And, “yeah, if I was Trump and I knew my rhetoric killed someone”. When
Ms. Pierson replied, “it wasn’t the rhetoric”. Mr. Pascal said, “Katrina, yes, it
was”. Thank you Mr. Chairman, I yield back.

BENNIE THOMPSON: Gentlelady yields back. We’re joined today by Mr. Jason Van Tatenhove
and Mr. Stephen Ayres. Mr. Tatenhove is an artist and journal — journalist. He’s
a former spokesman of the Oath Keepers and a former close associate of Elmer Stewart
Rhodes, the founder and President of the Oath Keepers, who has been charged with
seditious conspiracy in relation to the Capitol attack.

Mr. Van Tatenhove broke with the Oath Keepers and has since spoken out forcefully
against a violent group. Mr. Ayres is a former supporter of President Trump. He 
answered the President’s call to come to Washington DC on January 6th. He marched
to the Capitol on the President’s orders. He pleaded guilty last month to disorderly
and disruptive conduct at the Capitol.

Mr. Ayres, who no longer supports President Trump, came forward voluntarily to share
his story as a warning. I will now swear in our witnesses. The witnesses will please
stand and raise their right hand. Do you swear or affirm on the penalty of perjury
that the testimony you’re about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing
but the truth.

So help you God.

UNKNOWN: [off-mic]

BENNIE THOMPSON: Thank you. You may be seated. Let the record reflect that the witnesses
answered in the affirmative. I recognize myself for questions. Today we’ve discussed
how President Trump summoned an angry mob of supporters to Washington, DC, many 
of whom came prepared to do battle against police and politicians alike.

We’re fortunate enough to be joined by two witnesses who can help us understand 
who was in the mob that day. Both hard core violent extremists like the Oath Keepers
and Proud Boys and average Trump supporters swept up in the fervor of the day. Mr.
Van Tatenhove, can you help us understand who the Oath Keepers are?

JASON VAN TATENHOVE: I can. Thank you. My time with the Oath Keepers began back 
at Bondy Ranch with that first standoff when I went to cover them as an independent
journalist. I then subsequently covered two more standoffs, the Sugar Pine Mine 
standoff and the White Hope Mine standoff. It was at that time that I was offered
a job as national media director and an associate editor for the Web page.

So I spent a few years with the Oath Keepers and I can tell you that they may not
like to call themselves a militia, but they are. They’re a violent militia. And 
they are largely Stewart Rhodes. They — and I think rather than try to use words,
I think the — the best illustration for what the Oath Keepers are happened January
6th when we saw that stacked military formation going up the stairs of our Capitol.
I saw radicalization that started with my beginning of my time with them and continued
over a period of time as the member base and who it was that Stewart Rhodes was 
courting drifted further and further right into the alt right world into white nationalists
and even straight up racists. And it came to a point where I could no longer continue
to — to work for them, but the Oath Keepers are — are a dangerous militia that that
is in large part fed by the ego and drive of Stewart Rhodes to at times seemed to
see himself as this paramilitary leader.

I think that drove a lot of it. So in my opinion, the Oath Keepers are a very dangerous
organization.

BENNIE THOMPSON: Well, thank you very much. You’ve talked a little bit about that
danger. So what is the Oath Keepers’ vision for America and why should Americans
be concerned about it?

JASON VAN TATENHOVE: I think we saw a glimpse of what the vision of the Oath Keepers
is on January 6th. It doesn’t necessarily include the rule of law. It doesn’t necessarily
include — it includes violence. It includes trying to — to get their way through
lies, through deceit, through intimidation, and through the perpetration of violence,
the swaying of — of people who may not know better through lies and rhetoric and
propaganda that can get swept up in these moments.

And I will admit I was swept up at one point as well too. But — and I don’t know
if that answers the question.

BENNIE THOMPSON: Well, it does. And you talk about being swept up. So at what point
did you break with the Oath Keepers?

JASON VAN TATENHOVE: There came a point — there were many red flags and I probably
should have broke with them much earlier than I did. But the straw that broke the
camel’s back really came when I walked into a grocery store. We were living up in
the very remote town of Eureka, Montana and there was a group of core members of
the group of the Oath Keepers and some associates, and they were having a conversation
at that public area where they were talking about how the Holocaust was not real.

And that was for me something I just could not abide. And you know, we were not —
we were not wealthy people at all. We were barely surviving. And it didn’t matter—
I went home to my wife and my kids, and I told them that I’ve got to walk away at
this point. I don’t know how we’re going to survive or where we’re going to go or
what we’re going to do, but I just can no longer continue, and put in my resignation.

BENNIE THOMPSON: Thank you very much. Mr. Ayres, there were many people in the crowd
that day on January 6, including you, who were not part of an extremist group. I’d
like to start by having you tell the American people a little bit about yourself.
Can you tell us about your life before January 6th?

STEPHEN AYRES: Yeah. Basically, nothing but a family man and a working man. Worked
at the company, a cabinet company up in Northeast Ohio for going on 20 years. You
know, family is my life. You know, I was a supervisor there, so that that took up
a lot of my other — you know, a lot of my free time. Other than that, with my family
camping, playing basketball, playing games with my son.

BENNIE THOMPSON: Just what any ordinary American citizen, family man, would do.

STEPHEN AYRES: Yeah, exactly.

BENNIE THOMPSON: So this committee has reviewed thousands of hours of surveillance
footage from January 6. During this review, we identified you entering the Capitol
as we see in this video. Mr. Ayres, why did you decide to come to Washington on 
January 6th?

STEPHEN AYRES: For me, for me personally, you know — I was, you know, pretty hardcore
into the social media, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram. I followed, you know, President
Trump, you know, on all the websites, you know. He basically put out, you know, 
come to the Stop the Steal rally, you know, and I felt like I needed to be down 
here.

BENNIE THOMPSON: So — so you basically learned about the rally on social media, 
and at some point made a decision to come to Washington.

STEPHEN AYRES: Yeah, yeah. I had some friends I found out were coming down. I just
hopped — you know, hopped on with them right at the tail end when I found out, and
Came down here with them.

BENNIE THOMPSON: Thank you very much. The Chair recognizes the Vice Chair Ms. Cheney
of Wyoming with any questions that she may have.

LIZ CHENEY: Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Ayers, when you entered the Capitol
last year, did you believe that the election had been stolen? At that time, yeah.
You know, everything that I was — I was seeing online, I definitely believed that
that’s exactly what — that was the case. And when you heard from President Trump
that the election was stolen, how did that make you feel?

STEPHEN AYRES: Oh, I was, you know, I was very upset, as were most of his supporters.
You know, that’s basically what got me to come down here.

LIZ CHENEY: And do you still believe the election was stolen?

STEPHEN AYRES: Not so much now. I got away from all the social media when January
6 happened, basically deleted it all. You know, I started doing my own research 
and everything. And for me — for me for something like that to be that — to actually
for that to actually take place, it’s too big, you know. There’d be — there’s no
way you can keep something like that quiet, as big as something like that.

You know, with all the, you know, all the lawsuits being shot down one after another,
that — that was mainly what convinced me.

LIZ CHENEY: Well, and I think that’s very important. And we’ve also talked about
today and in previous hearings the extent to which the President himself was told
that the election hadn’t been stolen, by his Justice Department, by his White House
counsel, by his campaign. Would it have made a difference to you to know that President
Trump himself had no evidence of widespread fraud?

STEPHEN AYRES: Oh, definitely, you know. Who knows, I may not have come down here
then, you know.

LIZ CHENEY: Thank you very much. Mr. Chairman, I yield back.

BENNIE THOMPSON: The gentlelady yields back. The chair recognizes the gentlewoman
from Florida, Ms. Murphy.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Thank you. Mr. Chairman. You know, earlier today we showed how
Donald Trump’s December 19th tweet summoned both extremist groups as well as rank
and file supporters of President Trump to come to Washington, DC, average Americans.
He — he told them to, quote, be there, will be wild; and they came. We showed how
Mr. President — how President Trump repeatedly told them fight, fight, fight, and
they marched to the Capitol.

Mr. Ayres, you were in that crowd at the rally, and then the crowd that marched 
to the Capitol. When you arrived on the Ellipse that morning, were you planning 
on going to the Capitol?

STEPHEN AYRES: No, we didn’t actually plan to go down there. You know, we went basically
to see the Stop the Steal rally and that was it.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: So why did you decide to march to the Capitol?

STEPHEN AYRES: Well, basically, you know, the President got everybody riled up and
told everybody to head on down. So we basically was just following what he said.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: After the President’s speech as you’re marching down to the Capitol,
how did you feel?

STEPHEN AYRES: I was, you know, I’m angry. You know, after everything that was basically
said in the speech. You know, a lot of the stuff he said he already put out in tweets.
I’ve already seen it and heard it before. So, I mean, I was already worked up and
so were most of the people there.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: So as you started marching, did you think there was still a chance
the election would be overturned?

STEPHEN AYRES: Yeah, at that time I did, you know, because everybody was kind of
like in the hope that, you know, Vice President Pence was not going to certify the
election. You know, also the whole time on our way down there, we kept hearing about
this big reveal I remember us talking about, and we kind of thought maybe that was
it. So that hope was there.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Did you think that the President would be marching with you?

STEPHEN AYRES: Yeah, I think everybody thought he was going to be coming down. You
know, he said it in his speech, you know, kind of like he’s going to be there with
us. So, I mean, I think — I believed it.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: I understand. We know that you illegally entered the Capitol that
afternoon and then left the Capitol area later on. What made you decide to leave?

STEPHEN AYRES: Basically, when President Trump put his tweet out. We literally left
right after that come out. You know, to me if he would have done that earlier in
the day, 1:30, I — you know, we wouldn’t be in this — maybe we wouldn’t be in this
bad of a situation or something.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I yield back.

BENNIE THOMPSON: The Chair recognizes the gentleman from Maryland, Mr. Raskin.

JAMIE RASKIN: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Van Tatenhove, in the run-up to January
6, Stewart Rhodes publicly implored President Trump to invoke the Insurrection Act,
the 1807 law that allows the President to call up militias to put down a rebellion
against the United States. And I want to get your thoughts about this in the context
of your prior relationship with Stewart Rhodes.

I understand that you had conversations with Rhodes about the Insurrection Act. 
Why was he so fixated on that, and what did he think it would enable the Oath Keepers
to do?

JASON VAN TATENHOVE: Well, I think it gave him a sense of legitimacy, that it was
a path forward to move forward with his goals and agendas. I think we need to quit
mincing words and just talk about truths, and what it was going to be was an armed
revolution. I mean, people died that day. Law enforcement officers died this day.
There was a gallows set up in front of the Capitol. This could have been the spark
that started a new civil war, and no one would have won there. That would have been
good for no one. He was always looking for ways to legitimize what he was doing,
whether by wrapping it in the trappings of, it’s not a militia, it’s a community
preparedness team.

We’re not a militia, we’re an educational outreach group. It’s a veterans support
group. But again, we’ve got to stop with this — this dishonesty and the mincing 
of words and just call things for what they are. You know, he’s a militia leader.
He had these grand visions of being a paramilitary leader, and the Insurrection 
Act would have given him a path forward with that.

You know, the fact that the President was communicating, whether directly or indirectly
messaging, you know, kind of that gave him the nod. And all I can do is thank the
gods that things did not go any worse that day.

JAMIE RASKIN: What did the Oath Keepers see in President Trump?

JASON VAN TATENHOVE: They saw a path forward that would have legitimacy. They saw
opportunity, I think, in my opinion, to become a paramilitary force, you know.

JAMIE RASKIN: Last week, the Department of Justice indicated that it has evidence
of the Oath Keepers bringing not just firearms but explosives to Washington ahead
of January 6th. And the committee has also learned that Stewart Rhodes stopped to
buy weapons on his way to Washington, and shipped roughly $7,000 worth of tactical
gear to a January 6th rally planner in Virginia before the attack.

Did you ever hear Rhodes discuss committing violence against elected political leaders?

JASON VAN TATENHOVE: Yeah, I mean, that went back from the very beginning of my 
tenure. One of the first assignments that he brought to me, wanting me to do as 
more of a graphic artist function was to create a deck of cards. You may remember
back to the conflict in the Middle East where our own military created a deck of
cards, which was a who’s who of kind of the — the key players on the other side 
that they wanted to take out.

And Stewart was very intrigued by that notion and influenced by it, I think. And
he wanted me to create a deck of cards that would include different politicians,
judges, including up to Hillary Clinton as the queen of hearts. This was a project
that I refused to do. But from the very start, we saw that. There was always the—
the push for military training, including there were — there were — there were courses
in that community that went over explosives training.

So, yeah, this all falls in line.

JAMIE RASKIN: Mr. Van Tatenhove, you say in your very thoughtful written testimony
that we received today that you fear what the next election cycle will bring. And
you also say that we have been exceedingly lucky, in that we have not seen more 
bloodshed so far. I wonder if you would elaborate on those two statements.

JASON VAN TATENHOVE: I think, as far as the luck goes, we’ve had the potential from
Bundy Ranch on. I mean, being boots on the ground at these — these standoffs, and
they were standoffs, where there were firearms pointed across lines at federal law
enforcement agencies. You know, whatever it may be with that particular standoff.

But I do — I think we’ve gotten exceedingly lucky that more bloodshed did not happen,
because the potential has been there from the start. And we got very lucky that 
the loss of life was — and as tragic as it is that we saw on January 6th, the potential
was so much more.

Again, all we have to look at is the iconic images of that day with the gallows 
set up for Mike Pence, for the Vice President of the United States, you know.

And I do fear for this next election cycle, because who knows what that might bring?
If — if a president that’s willing to try to instill and encourage to whip up a 
civil war amongst his followers using lies and deceit and snake oil, and regardless
of the human impact, what else is he going to do if he gets elected again?

All bets are off at that point, and that’s a scary notion. I have three daughters;
I have a granddaughter. And I fear for the world that they will inherit if we do
not start holding these — these people to account.

JAMIE RASKIN: Thank you for your testimony, Mr. Van Tatenhove. Mr. Ayres, I first
want to ask you about what finally caused you to leave on January the 6th. We know
that the medieval style combat with our police, the occupation of the building, 
this was going on for several hours until the President issued at 4:17 a tweet, 
I believe that included a video, telling people to go home.

Did you see that, and did that have any effect on what you were doing?

STEPHEN AYRES: Well, when we were there, as soon as that come out, everybody started
talking about it and that’s — it seemed like it started to disperse. You know, some
of the crowd, obviously, you know, once we got back to the hotel room, we seen that
it was still going on. But it definitely dispersed a lot of the crowd.

JAMIE RASKIN: And did you leave at that point?

STEPHEN AYRES: Yeah, we did. Yeah, we left.

JAMIE RASKIN: So, in other words, that was the key moment when you decided to leave
when President Trump told people to go home.

STEPHEN AYRES: Yeah, yeah, we left right when that come out.

JAMIE RASKIN: You were not a member of an organized group like the Oath Keepers 
or the Proud Boys, as most of the crowd wasn’t. I wonder on January 6th, was it 
your view that these far-right groups like the Oath Keepers and Proud Boys and Three
Percenters and others were on your side? Did you have any reservations about marching
with them and rallying with them?

STEPHEN AYRES: Well, I definitely didn’t have a problem, you know. I was probably
following them online myself. You know, I liked — I thought, you know, hey, they’re
on our team; good. That’s how I kind of looked at it at the time, you know, like
I didn’t have a problem with it. I thought it was a good thing.

JAMIE RASKIN: I’m interested in hearing about what’s happened to you since the events
of January 6th. You told the vice chair that you no longer believe Trump’s big lie
about the election, but that’s what brought you originally to Washington. Looking
back on it now, how do you reflect on the role that you played in the crowd that
day, and what is going on in your life?

STEPHEN AYRES: Basically, you know, I lost my job. Since this all happened, you 
know, pretty much sold my house. So everything that happened with the charges, you
know, thank God, a lot of them did get dismissed because I was just holding my phone.
But at the same time, I was there. So, I mean, it definitely — it changed my life,
you know, and not for the good.

Definitely not for the, you know, for the better. Yeah, I mean, really all I can
say.

JAMIE RASKIN: Well, President Trump is still promoting the big lie about the election.
How does that make you feel?

STEPHEN AYRES: It makes me mad because I — I was hanging on every word he was saying.
Everything he was putting out, I was following it. I mean, if I was doing it, hundreds
of thousands or millions of other people are doing it, or maybe even still doing
it. It’s like he just said about that, you know, you got people still following 
and doing that.

Who knows what the next election could come out, you know. It could end up being
down the same path we are right now. I mean, just don’t know.

JAMIE RASKIN: Mr. Ayres, I see that your wife has joined you today, and welcome 
to Washington. We know this has been very difficult on you both and your family.
What lessons finally do you want the American people to learn from the way you and
your family have suffered as a result of these events?

STEPHEN AYRES: The biggest thing is I consider myself a family man, and I love my
country. I don’t think any one man is bigger than either one of those. I think that’s
what needed to be taken, you know. People dive into the politics, and for me I felt
like I had, you know, like horse blinders on. I was — I was locked in the whole 
time. Biggest thing for me is take the blinders off, make sure you step back and
see what’s going on before it’s too late.

JAMIE RASKIN: Well, I want to thank you for your testimony and for appearing, both
of you, today. And Mr. Chairman, I yield back to you.

BENNIE THOMPSON: The gentleman yields back. I want to thank our witnesses for joining
us today. The members of the select committee may have additional questions for 
today’s witnesses, and we ask that you respond expeditiously in writing to those
questions. Without objections, members will be permitted ten business days to submit
statements for the record, including opening remarks and additional questions for
the witnesses.

Without objection, the Chair recognizes the gentleman from Maryland, Mr. Raskin,
for a closing statement.

JAMIE RASKIN: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. When Donald Trump sent out his tweet, he 
became the first President ever to call for a crowd to descend on the capital city
to block the constitutional transfer of power. He set off an explosive chain reaction
among his followers, but no one mobilized more quickly than the dangerous extremists
that we’ve looked at today.

Seizing upon his invitation to fight, they assembled their followers for an insurrectionary
showdown against Congress and the Vice President. On January 6, Trump knew the crowd
was angry. He knew the crowd was armed. He sent them to the Capitol anyway. You 
might imagine that our founders would have been shocked to learn that an American
President would one day come to embrace and excuse political violence against our
own institutions, or knowingly send an armed mob to attack the Capitol to usurp 
the will of the people. But, you know, Mr. Chairman, the founders were pretty wise
about certain things. And at the start of the republic, they actually warned everyone
about Donald Trump. Not by name, of course, but in the course of advising about 
the certain prospect that ambitious politicians would try to mobilize violent mobs
to tear down our own institutions in service of their insatiable ambitions.

In the very first Federalist Paper, Alexander Hamilton observed that history teaches
that opportunistic politicians who desire to rule at all costs will begin first 
as demagogues, pandering to the angry and malignant passions of the crowd, but then
end up as tyrants, trampling the freedoms and the rights of the people.

A violent insurrection to overturn an election is not an abstract thing, as we’ve
heard. Hundreds of people were bloodied, injured, and wounded in the process, including
more than 150 police officers, some of them sitting in this room today. I want to
give you an update on one officer who was badly wounded in the attack and is well
known to the members of this committee, because he testified before us last year.

Sergeant Aquilino Gonell is an Army veteran who spent a year on active combat duty
in the Iraq war and then 16 years on the Capitol force. Nothing he ever saw in combat
in Iraq, he has said, prepared him for the insurrection where he was savagely beaten,
punched, pushed, kicked, shoved, stomped, and sprayed with chemical irritants, along
with other officers, by members of a mob carrying hammers, knives, batons, and police
shields, taken by force and wielding the American flag against police officers as
a dangerous weapon.

Last month on June 28th, Sergeant Gonell’s team of doctors told him that permanent
injuries he has suffered to his left shoulder and right foot now make it impossible
for him to continue as a police officer. He must leave policing for good and figure
out the rest of his life. Sergeant Gonell, we wish you and your family all the best.

We are here for you. We salute you for your valor, your eloquence, and your beautiful
commitment to America. I wonder what former President Trump would say to someone
like Sergeant Gonell who must now go about remaking his life. I wonder if he could
even understand what motivates a patriot like Sergeant Gonell. In his inaugural 
address, Trump introduced one commanding image, American carnage. Although that 
turn of phrase explained little about our country before he took office, it turned
out to be an excellent prophecy of what his rage would come to visit on our people.
Mr. Ayres just described how the trust he placed in President Trump as a camp follower
derailed his life and nearly wrecked his reputation and his family.

A few weeks ago, we heard Shaye Moss and her mother Ruby Freeman, Speaker Rusty 
Bowers from Arizona, and Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger describe 
how hate-filled intimidation campaigns by Trump and his followers made them prisoners
in their homes, and drove their stress and anxiety to soaring new heights when they
refused to do Trump’s bidding.

American carnage, that’s Donald Trump’s true legacy. His desire to overthrow the
people’s election and seize the presidency interrupted the counting of Electoral
College votes for the first time in American history, nearly toppled the constitutional
order, and brutalized hundreds and hundreds of people. The Watergate break-in was
like a Cub Scout meeting compared to this assault on our people and our institutions.

Mr. Chairman, these hearings have been significant for us and for millions of Americans.
And our hearing next week will be a profound moment of reckoning for America. But
the crucial thing is the next step, what this committee — what all of us will do
to fortify our democracy against coups, political violence, and campaigns to steal
elections away from the people.

Unlike Mr. Ayres and Mr. Van Tatenhove, people who have recovered and evolved from
their descent into the hell of fanaticism, Donald Trump has only expanded his big
lie. To cover January 6th itself, he asserts the insurrection was the real election,
and the election was the real insurrection. He says his mob greeted our police officers
on January 6th with hugs and kisses.

He threatens to take one of America’s two major political parties with him down 
the road to authoritarianism. And it is Abraham Lincoln’s party, no less. The political
scientists tell us that authoritarian parties have two essential features in common,
in history and around the world. They do not accept the results of democratic elections
when they lose, and they embrace political violence as legitimate.

And the problem — and the problem of incitement to political violence has only grown
more serious in the Internet age, as we have just heard. But this is not the problem
of one party; it is the problem of the whole country now. American democracy, Mr.
Chairman, is a precious inheritance, something rare in the history of the world 
and even on earth today.

Constitutional democracy is the silver frame, as Lincoln put it, upon which the 
golden apple of freedom rests. We need to defend both our democracy and our freedom
with everything we have, and declare that this American carnage ends here and now.
In a world of resurgent authoritarianism and racism and anti-Semitism, let’s all
hang tough for American democracy.

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back.

BENNIE THOMPSON: The gentleman yields back. Without objection, the Chair recognizes
the gentlewoman from Florida, Ms. Murphy, for a closing statement.

STEPHANIE MURPHY: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. At one of our first hearings, Chairman
Thompson explained that the members of this committee would not spend much time 
talking about ourselves. Rather, we would let the evidence play the leading role.
And the Chairman was right, because this isn’t about promoting ourselves as Individuals.

It’s about protecting the country we love. And it’s about preserving what actually
makes America great: the rule of law, free and fair elections, and the peaceful 
transfer of power from one elected leader to the next. But if I may say a word about
myself and why I’m proud to serve on this committee, I’m the only member of this
committee who was not blessed to be born an American. I was born in Vietnam after
the Vietnam War, and my family and I fled a communist government and were rescued
by the US Navy, and were given sanctuary in America. My patriotism is rooted in 
my gratitude for America’s grace and generosity. I love this country. On January
6th, four decades after my family fled a place where political power was seized 
through violence, I was in the United States Capitol fleeing my fellow Americans.

Members of the angry mob had been lied to by a President and other powerful people
who tried to convince them without evidence that the election had been stolen from
them. Some of them then tried to use physical violence to overturn the outcome of
a free and fair election. Our committee’s overriding objective is to fight fiction
with facts; to create a full account for the American people and for the historical
record; to tell the truth of what happened and why it happened; to make recommendations
so it never happens again; to defend our democracy.

To me, there’s nothing more patriotic than that. Thank you. Mr. Chairman, I yield
back.

BENNIE THOMPSON: The gentlelady yields back. Without objection, the Chair recognizes
the gentlewoman from Wyoming, Ms. Cheney, for a closing statement.

LIZ CHENEY: Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, let me put what you
have seen today in a broader context. At the very outset of our hearings, we described
several elements of President Trump’s multipart plan to overturn the 2020 election.
Our hearings have now covered all but one of those elements, an organized campaign
to persuade millions of Americans of a falsehood that the 2020 election was stolen
by widespread fraud; a corrupt effort to pressure Vice President Pence to refuse
to count electoral votes; an effort to corrupt the US Department of Justice; efforts
to pressure state election officials and legislators to change state election results;
a scheme to create and submit fake electoral slates from multiple states. And today,
you saw how President Trump summoned a mob to Washington for January 6th, and then
knowing that that mob was armed, directed that mob to the United States Capitol.
Every one of these elements of the planning for January 6th is an independently 
serious matter. They were all ultimately focused on overturning the election, and
they all have one other thing in common.

Donald Trump participated in each, substantially and personally. He oversaw or directed
the activity of those involved. Next week, we will return to January 6th itself.
As we have shown in prior hearings, Donald Trump and his legal team led by Rudy 
Giuliani were working on January 6th — delay or halt Congress’s counting of electoral
votes.

The mob attacking and invading the Capitol on that afternoon of January 6th was 
achieving that result. And for multiple hours, Donald Trump refused to intervene
to stop it. He would not instruct the mob to leave or condemn the violence. He would
not order them to evacuate the Capitol and disperse. The many pleas for help from
Congress did no good.

His staff insisted that President Trump call off the attack. He would not. Here 
are a few of the many things you will hear next week from Mr. Cipollone. [Begin 
Videotape] [off-mic]

UNKNOWN: — is that right?

PAT CIPOLLONE: I was. And others were as well.

UNKNOWN: Ok. Was it necessary for you to continue to push for a statement directing
people to leave all the way through that period of time until it was ultimately 
issued after —

PAT CIPOLLONE: I felt it was my obligation to continue to push for that and others
felt that it was their obligation as well.

UNKNOWN: Would it have been possible at any moment for the President to walk down
to the podium in the briefing room and — and talk to the nation at any time between
when you first gave him that advice at 2:00 and 4:17 when the video statement went
out? Would that have been possible?

PAT CIPOLLONE: Would it have been possible?

UNKNOWN: Yes.

PAT CIPOLLONE: Yes, it would have been possible. [End Videotape]

LIZ CHENEY: And you will hear that Donald Trump never picked up the phone that day
to order his administration to help. This is not ambiguous. He did not call the 
military. His Secretary of Defense received no order. He did not call his attorney
general. He did not talk to the Department of Homeland Security. Mike Pence did 
all of those things.

Donald Trump did not. We will walk through the events of January 6th next week minute
by minute. And one more item, after our last hearing, President Trump tried to call
a witness in our investigation. A witness you have not yet seen in these hearings.
That person declined to answer or respond to President Trump’s call and instead 
alerted their lawyer to the call.

Their lawyer alerted us and this committee has supplied that information to the 
Department of Justice. Let me say one more time, we will take any effort to influence
witness testimony very seriously. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I yield back.

BENNIE THOMPSON: Thank you. Gentlelady yields back. In my opening, I mentioned how
we look to our leaders to serve as a failsafe if people in this country refuse to
accept the results of an election. That’s part of the way those in positions of 
public trust uphold their oath, how they show fidelity to the Constitution. In the
run up to January 6th, Donald Trump had an obligation to tell his supporters to 
accept the results of the election.

Instead he urged them to further along the path toward mob violence. The idea of
mob violence make me think of another sort of fail safe. All across this country,
there are different ideas about what role the federal government should play in 
our lives. In fact, [untranslated] there are plenty of different ideas, but there
are moments when the institutions of our federal government are the failsafe.

I am from a part of the country where had it not been for the federal government
and the Constitution my parents and many more Americans like them would have continued
to be treated as second class citizens. The freedom to be able to vote without harassment,
travel in relative safety, and dine and sleep where you choose is because we have
a government that looks over the well-being of its citizens.

This is especially important in moments of crisis. When we have a natural disaster
that state governments can’t handle on their own, when there’s an emergency that’s[
requires] action by public health services or our military, we have a federal government.
What happened on January 6, 2020 was another one of those moments in history that
test the strength of our federal government.

January 6th was an attack on our country. It was an attack on our democracy, on 
our Constitution. A sitting President with a violent mob trying to stop the peaceful
transfer of power from one President to another. It still makes my blood boil to
think of it. In a moment like that, what would you expect to see?

You expect to see the President of the United States sitting behind the resolute
desk in the Oval Office assuring the American people that the attack would be repelled
and a threat would be dealt with. You would expect to be reassured that there was
a failsafe. Instead the President of the United States sent the mob.

He disregarded the advice of the people who had taken an oath to the Constitution.
He oversaw a scheme aided by people whose loyalty was only to Donald Trump. There’s
nothing we can compare that to. There’s nothing in our great nation’s history that
has ever come close to that sort of betrayal and dereliction.

Thank goodness our system of government held in spite of a Commander in Chief who
worked in opposition to what the Constitution desired. When this committee reconvenes,
we’ll tell the story of that supreme dereliction by the Commander in Chief, how 
close we came to a catastrophe for democracy, and how we remain in serious danger.

The Chair requests those in the hearing room remain seated until the Capitol Police
have escorted witnesses and members from the room. Without objection, the committee
stands adjourned.

List of Panel Members

PANEL MEMBERS:

REP. BENNIE THOMPSON (D-MISS.),

CHAIRMAN REP. ZOE LOFGREN (D-CALIF.)

REP. ADAM SCHIFF (D-CALIF.)

REP. PETE AGUILAR (D-CALIF.)

REP. STEPHANIE MURPHY (D-FLA.)
