# The Secret History of the Shadow Campaign That Saved the 2020 Election

- Link: https://kendreger.com/?p=427
- Published: 2021-02-05T22:04:00+07:00
- Author: ken

[⌊clip_image002⌉⌊clip_image002⌉[

Time Magazine February 15 Issue on the News Stands.

**The Secret History of the Shadow Campaign That Saved the 2020 Election**
_Time
Magazine: ‘Secret,’ ‘Well-funded Cabal’ Worked to ‘Protect’ 2020 Election

### 󠀁[⌊clip_image004⌉⌊clip_image004⌉󠀁[󠀁[⌊clip_image006⌉⌊clip_image006⌉󠀁[⏎ Illustration by Ryan Olbrysh for TIME Ted S. Warren/AP Photo

By [Molly Ball ](https://time.com/author/molly-ball/)
Molly Ball is TIME’s National
Political Correspondent. Previously, she covered U.S. politics for _The Atlantic_
and _Politico_, and worked for newspapers in Nevada and Cambodia. She is the author
of [_Pelosi_](https://www.amazon.com/Pelosi-Molly-Ball/dp/1250252865), a bestselling
biography of the first woman Speaker of the House.

February 4, 2021 5:40 AM EST

**A weird thing happened right after the Nov. 3 election: nothing.**

The nation was braced for chaos. Liberal groups had vowed to take to the streets,
planning hundreds of protests across the country. Right-wing militias were girding
for battle. In a poll before Election Day, 75% of Americans voiced concern about
violence.

Instead, an eerie quiet descended. As President Trump refused to concede, the response
was not mass action but crickets. When media organizations called the race for Joe
Biden on Nov. 7, jubilation broke out instead, as people thronged cities across 
the U.S. to celebrate the democratic process that resulted in Trump’s ouster.

**Reactions Throughout the U.S. After Biden Wins Presidential Race in Unprecedented
Election**

A second odd thing happened amid Trump’s attempts to reverse the result: corporate
America turned on him. Hundreds of major business leaders, many of whom had backed
Trump’s candidacy and supported his policies, called on him to concede. To the President,
something felt amiss. “It was all very, very strange,” Trump said on Dec. 2. “Within
days after the election, we witnessed an orchestrated effort to anoint the winner,
even while many key states were still being counted.”

**In a way, Trump was right.**

There was a conspiracy unfolding behind the scenes, one that both curtailed the 
protests and coordinated the resistance from CEOs. Both surprises were the result
of an informal alliance between left-wing activists and business titans. The pact
was formalized in a terse, little-noticed joint statement of the U.S. Chamber of
Commerce and AFL-CIO published on Election Day. Both sides would come to see it 
as a sort of implicit bargain–inspired by the summer’s massive, sometimes destructive
racial-justice protests–in which the forces of labor came together with the forces
of capital to keep the peace and oppose Trump’s assault on democracy.

The handshake between business and labor was just one component of a vast, cross-
partisan campaign to protect the election–an extraordinary shadow effort dedicated
not to winning the vote but to ensuring it would be free and fair, credible and 
uncorrupted. For more than a year, a loosely organized coalition of operatives scrambled
to shore up America’s institutions as they came under simultaneous attack from a
remorseless pandemic and an autocratically inclined President. Though much of this
activity took place on the left, it was separate from the Biden campaign and crossed
ideological lines, with crucial contributions by nonpartisan and conservative actors.
The scenario the shadow campaigners were desperate to stop was not a Trump victory.
It was an election so calamitous that no result could be discerned at all, a failure
of the central act of democratic self-governance that has been a hallmark of America
since its founding.

Their work touched every aspect of the election. They got states to change voting
systems and laws and helped secure hundreds of millions in public and private funding.
They fended off voter-suppression lawsuits, recruited armies of poll workers and
got millions of people to vote by mail for the first time. They successfully pressured
social media companies to take a harder line against disinformation and used data-
driven strategies to fight viral smears. They executed national public-awareness
campaigns that helped Americans understand how the vote count would unfold over 
days or weeks, preventing Trump’s conspiracy theories and false claims of victory
from getting more traction. After Election Day, they monitored every pressure point
to ensure that Trump could not overturn the result. “The untold story of the election
is the thousands of people of both parties who accomplished the triumph of American
democracy at its very foundation,” says Norm Eisen, a prominent lawyer and former
Obama Administration official who recruited Republicans and Democrats to the board
of the Voter Protection Program.

For Trump and his allies were running their own campaign to spoil the election. 
The President spent months insisting that mail ballots were a Democratic plot and
the election would be “rigged.” His henchmen at the state level sought to block 
their use, while his lawyers brought dozens of spurious suits to make it more difficult
to vote–an intensification of the GOP’s legacy of suppressive tactics. Before the
election, Trump plotted to block a legitimate vote count. And he spent the months
following Nov. 3 trying to steal the election he’d lost–with lawsuits and conspiracy
theories, pressure on state and local officials, and finally summoning his army 
of supporters to the Jan. 6 rally that ended in deadly violence at the Capitol.

The democracy campaigners watched with alarm. “Every week, we felt like we were 
in a struggle to try to pull off this election without the country going through
a real dangerous moment of unraveling,” says former GOP Representative Zach Wamp,
a Trump supporter who helped coordinate a bipartisan election-protection council.“
We can look back and say this thing went pretty well, but it was not at all clear
in September and October that that was going to be the case.”

[⌊clip_image008⌉⌊clip_image008⌉[

Biden fans in Philadelphia after the race was called on Nov. 7
Michelle Gustafson
for TIME

This is the inside story of the conspiracy to save the 2020 election, based on access
to the group’s inner workings, never-before-seen documents and interviews with dozens
of those involved from across the political spectrum. It is the story of an unprecedented,
creative and determined campaign whose success also reveals how close the nation
came to disaster. “Every attempt to interfere with the proper outcome of the election
was defeated,” says Ian Bassin, co-founder of Protect Democracy, a nonpartisan rule-
of-law advocacy group. “But it’s massively important for the country to understand
that it didn’t happen accidentally. The system didn’t work magically. Democracy 
is not self-executing.”

That’s why the participants want the secret history of the 2020 election told, even
though it sounds like a paranoid fever dream–a well-funded cabal of powerful people,
ranging across industries and ideologies, working together behind the scenes to 
influence perceptions, change rules and laws, steer media coverage and control the
flow of information. They were not rigging the election; they were fortifying it.
And they believe the public needs to understand the system’s fragility in order 
to ensure that democracy in America endures.

#### THE ARCHITECT

Sometime in the fall of 2019, Mike Podhorzer became convinced the election was headed
for disaster–and determined to protect it.

This was not his usual purview. For nearly a quarter-century, Podhorzer, senior 
adviser to the president of the AFL-CIO, the nation’s largest union federation, 
has marshaled the latest tactics and data to help its favored candidates win elections.
Unassuming and professorial, he isn’t the sort of hair-gelled “political strategist”
who shows up on cable news. Among Democratic insiders, he’s known as the wizard 
behind some of the biggest advances in political technology in recent decades. A
group of liberal strategists he brought together in the early 2000s led to the creation
of the Analyst Institute, a secretive firm that applies scientific methods to political
campaigns. He was also involved in the founding of Catalist, the flagship progressive
data company.

The endless chatter in Washington about “political strategy,” Podhorzer believes,
has little to do with how change really gets made. “My basic take on politics is
that it’s all pretty obvious if you don’t overthink it or swallow the prevailing
frameworks whole,” he once wrote. “After that, just relentlessly identify your assumptions
and challenge them.” Podhorzer applies that approach to everything: when he coached
his now adult son’s Little League team in the D.C. suburbs, he trained the boys 
not to swing at most pitches–a tactic that infuriated both their and their opponents’
parents, but won the team a series of championships.

Trump’s election in 2016–credited in part to his unusual strength among the sort
of blue collar white voters who once dominated the AFL-CIO–prompted Podhorzer to
question his assumptions about voter behavior. He began circulating weekly number-
crunching memos to a small circle of allies and hosting strategy sessions in D.C.
But when he began to worry about the election itself, he didn’t want to seem paranoid.
It was only after months of research that he introduced his concerns in his newsletter
in October 2019. The usual tools of data, analytics and polling would not be sufficient
in a situation where the President himself was trying to disrupt the election, he
wrote. “Most of our planning takes us through Election Day,” he noted. “But, we 
are not prepared for the two most likely outcomes”–Trump losing and refusing to 
concede, and Trump winning the Electoral College (despite losing the popular vote)
by corrupting the voting process in key states. “We desperately need to systematically‘
red-team’ this election so that we can anticipate and plan for the worst we know
will be coming our way.”

It turned out Podhorzer wasn’t the only one thinking in these terms. He began to
hear from others eager to join forces. The Fight Back Table, a coalition of “resistance”
organizations, had begun scenario-planning around the potential for a contested 
election, gathering liberal activists at the local and national level into what 
they called the Democracy Defense Coalition. Voting-rights and civil rights organizations
were raising alarms. A group of former elected officials was researching emergency
powers they feared Trump might exploit. Protect Democracy was assembling a bipartisan
election-crisis task force. “It turned out that once you said it out loud, people
agreed,” Podhorzer says, “and it started building momentum.”

He spent months pondering scenarios and talking to experts. It wasn’t hard to find
liberals who saw Trump as a dangerous dictator, but Podhorzer was careful to steer
clear of hysteria. What he wanted to know was not how American democracy was dying
but how it might be kept alive. The chief difference between the U.S. and countries
that lost their grip on democracy, he concluded, was that America’s decentralized
election system couldn’t be rigged in one fell swoop. That presented an opportunity
to shore it up.

#### THE ALLIANCE

On March 3, Podhorzer drafted a three-page confidential memo titled “Threats to 
the 2020 Election.” “Trump has made it clear that this will not be a fair election,
and that he will reject anything but his own re-election as ‘fake’ and rigged,” 
he wrote. “On Nov. 3, should the media report otherwise, he will use the right-wing
information system to establish his narrative and incite his supporters to protest.”
The memo laid out four categories of challenges: attacks on voters, attacks on election
administration, attacks on Trump’s political opponents and “efforts to reverse the
results of the election.”

Then COVID-19 erupted at the height of the primary-election season. Normal methods
of voting were no longer safe for voters or the mostly elderly volunteers who normally
staff polling places. But political disagreements, intensified by Trump’s crusade
against mail voting, prevented some states from making it easier to vote absentee
and for jurisdictions to count those votes in a timely manner. Chaos ensued. Ohio
shut down in-person voting for its primary, leading to minuscule turnout. A poll-
worker shortage in Milwaukee–where Wisconsin’s heavily Democratic Black population
is concentrated–left just five open polling places, down from 182. In New York, 
vote counting took more than a month.

Suddenly, the potential for a November meltdown was obvious. In his apartment in
the D.C. suburbs, Podhorzer began working from his laptop at his kitchen table, 
holding back-to-back Zoom meetings for hours a day with his network of contacts 
across the progressive universe: the labor movement; the institutional left, like
Planned Parenthood and Greenpeace; resistance groups like Indivisible and MoveOn;
progressive data geeks and strategists, representatives of donors and foundations,
state-level grassroots organizers, racial-justice activists and others.

In April, Podhorzer began hosting a weekly 2½-hour Zoom. It was structured around
a series of rapid-fire five-minute presentations on everything from which ads were
working to messaging to legal strategy. The invitation-only gatherings soon attracted
hundreds, creating a rare shared base of knowledge for the fractious progressive
movement. “At the risk of talking trash about the left, there’s not a lot of good
information sharing,” says Anat Shenker-Osorio, a close Podhorzer friend whose poll-
tested messaging guidance shaped the group’s approach. “There’s a lot of not-invented-
here syndrome, where people won’t consider a good idea if they didn’t come up with
it.”

The meetings became the galactic center for a constellation of operatives across
the left who shared overlapping goals but didn’t usually work in concert. The group
had no name, no leaders and no hierarchy, but it kept the disparate actors in sync.“
Pod played a critical behind-the-scenes role in keeping different pieces of the 
movement infrastructure in communication and aligned,” says Maurice Mitchell, national
director of the Working Families Party. “You have the litigation space, the organizing
space, the political people just focused on the W, and their strategies aren’t always
aligned. He allowed this ecosystem to work together.”

Protecting the election would require an effort of unprecedented scale. As 2020 
progressed, it stretched to Congress, Silicon Valley and the nation’s statehouses.
It drew energy from the summer’s racial-justice protests, many of whose leaders 
were a key part of the liberal alliance. And eventually it reached across the aisle,
into the world of Trump-skeptical Republicans appalled by his attacks on democracy.

#### SECURING THE VOTE

The first task was overhauling America’s balky election infrastructure–in the middle
of a pandemic. For the thousands of local, mostly nonpartisan officials who administer
elections, the most urgent need was money. They needed protective equipment like
masks, gloves and hand sanitizer. They needed to pay for postcards letting people
know they could vote absentee–or, in some states, to mail ballots to every voter.
They needed additional staff and scanners to process ballots.

In March, activists appealed to Congress to steer COVID relief money to election
administration. Led by the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, more
than 150 organizations signed a letter to every member of Congress seeking $2 billion
in election funding. It was somewhat successful: the CARES Act, passed later that
month, contained $400 million in grants to state election administrators. But the
next tranche of relief funding didn’t add to that number. It wasn’t going to be 
enough.

Private philanthropy stepped into the breach. An assortment of foundations contributed
tens of millions in election-administration funding. The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative
chipped in $300 million. “It was a failure at the federal level that 2,500 local
election officials were forced to apply for philanthropic grants to fill their needs,”
says Amber McReynolds, a former Denver election official who heads the nonpartisan
National Vote at Home Institute.

McReynolds’ two-year-old organization became a clearinghouse for a nation struggling
to adapt. The institute gave secretaries of state from both parties technical advice
on everything from which vendors to use to how to locate drop boxes. Local officials
are the most trusted sources of election information, but few can afford a press
secretary, so the institute distributed communications tool kits. In a presentation
to Podhorzer’s group, McReynolds detailed the importance of absentee ballots for
shortening lines at polling places and preventing an election crisis.

The institute’s work helped 37 states and D.C. bolster mail voting. But it wouldn’t
be worth much if people didn’t take advantage. Part of the challenge was logistical:
each state has different rules for when and how ballots should be requested and 
returned. The Voter Participation Center, which in a normal year would have deployed
canvassers door-to-door to get out the vote, instead conducted focus groups in April
and May to find out what would get people to vote by mail. In August and September,
it sent ballot applications to 15 million people in key states, 4.6 million of whom
returned them. In mailings and digital ads, the group urged people not to wait for
Election Day. “All the work we have done for 17 years was built for this moment 
of bringing democracy to people’s doorsteps,” says Tom Lopach, the center’s CEO.

The effort had to overcome heightened skepticism in some communities. Many Black
voters preferred to exercise their franchise in person or didn’t trust the mail.
National civil rights groups worked with local organizations to get the word out
that this was the best way to ensure one’s vote was counted. In Philadelphia, for
example, advocates distributed “voting safety kits” containing masks, hand sanitizer
and informational brochures. “We had to get the message out that this is safe, reliable,
and you can trust it,” says Hannah Fried of All Voting Is Local.

At the same time, Democratic lawyers battled a historic tide of pre-election litigation.
The pandemic intensified the parties’ usual tangling in the courts. But the lawyers
noticed something else as well. “The litigation brought by the Trump campaign, of
a piece with the broader campaign to sow doubt about mail voting, was making novel
claims and using theories no court has ever accepted,” says Wendy Weiser, a voting-
rights expert at the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU. “They read more like lawsuits
designed to send a message rather than achieve a legal outcome.”

In the end, nearly half the electorate cast ballots by mail in 2020, practically
a revolution in how people vote. About a quarter voted early in person. Only a quarter
of voters cast their ballots the traditional way: in person on Election Day.

#### THE DISINFORMATION DEFENSE

Bad actors spreading false information is nothing new. For decades, campaigns have
grappled with everything from anonymous calls claiming the election has been rescheduled
to fliers spreading nasty smears about candidates’ families. But Trump’s lies and
conspiracy theories, the viral force of social media and the involvement of foreign
meddlers made disinformation a broader, deeper threat to the 2020 vote.

Laura Quinn, a veteran progressive operative who co-founded Catalist, began studying
this problem a few years ago. She piloted a nameless, secret project, which she 
has never before publicly discussed, that tracked disinformation online and tried
to figure out how to combat it. One component was tracking dangerous lies that might
otherwise spread unnoticed. Researchers then provided information to campaigners
or the media to track down the sources and expose them.

The most important takeaway from Quinn’s research, however, was that engaging with
toxic content only made it worse. “When you get attacked, the instinct is to push
back, call it out, say, ‘This isn’t true,’” Quinn says. “But the more engagement
something gets, the more the platforms boost it. The algorithm reads that as, ‘Oh,
this is popular; people want more of it.’”

The solution, she concluded, was to pressure platforms to enforce their rules, both
by removing content or accounts that spread disinformation and by more aggressively
policing it in the first place. “The platforms have policies against certain types
of malign behavior, but they haven’t been enforcing them,” she says.

Quinn’s research gave ammunition to advocates pushing social media platforms to 
take a harder line. In November 2019, Mark Zuckerberg invited nine civil rights 
leaders to dinner at his home, where they warned him about the danger of the election-
related falsehoods that were already spreading unchecked. “It took pushing, urging,
conversations, brainstorming, all of that to get to a place where we ended up with
more rigorous rules and enforcement,” says Vanita Gupta, president and CEO of the
Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, who attended the dinner and also
met with Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey and others. (Gupta has been nominated for Associate
Attorney General by President Biden.) “It was a struggle, but we got to the point
where they understood the problem. Was it enough? Probably not. Was it later than
we wanted? Yes. But it was really important, given the level of official disinformation,
that they had those rules in place and were tagging things and taking them down.”

#### SPREADING THE WORD

Beyond battling bad information, there was a need to explain a rapidly changing 
election process. It was crucial for voters to understand that despite what Trump
was saying, mail-in votes weren’t susceptible to fraud and that it would be normal
if some states weren’t finished counting votes on election night.

Dick Gephardt, the Democratic former House leader turned high-powered lobbyist, 
spearheaded one coalition. “We wanted to get a really bipartisan group of former
elected officials, Cabinet secretaries, military leaders and so on, aimed mainly
at messaging to the public but also speaking to local officials–the secretaries 
of state, attorneys general, governors who would be in the eye of the storm–to let
them know we wanted to help,” says Gephardt, who worked his contacts in the private
sector to put $20 million behind the effort.

Wamp, the former GOP Congressman, worked through the nonpartisan reform group Issue
One to rally Republicans. “We thought we should bring some bipartisan element of
unity around what constitutes a free and fair election,” Wamp says. The 22 Democrats
and 22 Republicans on the National Council on Election Integrity met on Zoom at 
least once a week. They ran ads in six states, made statements, wrote articles and
alerted local officials to potential problems. “We had rabid Trump supporters who
agreed to serve on the council based on the idea that this is honest,” Wamp says.
This is going to be just as important, he told them, to convince the liberals when
Trump wins. “Whichever way it cuts, we’re going to stick together.”

The Voting Rights Lab and IntoAction created state-specific memes and graphics, 
spread by email, text, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok, urging that every
vote be counted. Together, they were viewed more than 1 billion times. Protect Democracy’s
election task force issued reports and held media briefings with high-profile experts
across the political spectrum, resulting in widespread coverage of potential election
issues and fact-checking of Trump’s false claims. The organization’s tracking polls
found the message was being heard: the percentage of the public that didn’t expect
to know the winner on election night gradually rose until by late October, it was
over 70%. A majority also believed that a prolonged count wasn’t a sign of problems.“
We knew exactly what Trump was going to do: he was going to try to use the fact 
that Democrats voted by mail and Republicans voted in person to make it look like
he was ahead, claim victory, say the mail-in votes were fraudulent and try to get
them thrown out,” says Protect Democracy’s Bassin. Setting public expectations ahead
of time helped undercut those lies.

[⌊clip_image010⌉⌊clip_image010⌉[

Amber McReynolds, Zach Wamp and Maurice Mitchell
Rachel Woolf for TIME; Erik Schelzig—
AP/Shutterstock; Holly Pickett—The New York Times/Redux

The alliance took a common set of themes from the research Shenker-Osorio presented
at Podhorzer’s Zooms. Studies have shown that when people don’t think their vote
will count or fear casting it will be a hassle, they’re far less likely to participate.
Throughout election season, members of Podhorzer’s group minimized incidents of 
voter intimidation and tamped down rising liberal hysteria about Trump’s expected
refusal to concede. They didn’t want to amplify false claims by engaging them, or
put people off voting by suggesting a rigged game. “When you say, ‘These claims 
of fraud are spurious,’ what people hear is ‘fraud,’” Shenker-Osorio says. “What
we saw in our pre-election research was that anything that reaffirmed Trump’s power
or cast him as an authoritarian diminished people’s desire to vote.”

Podhorzer, meanwhile, was warning everyone he knew that polls were underestimating
Trump’s support. The data he shared with media organizations who would be calling
the election was “tremendously useful” to understand what was happening as the votes
rolled in, according to a member of a major network’s political unit who spoke with
Podhorzer before Election Day. Most analysts had recognized there would be a “blue
shift” in key battlegrounds– the surge of votes breaking toward Democrats, driven
by tallies of mail-in ballots– but they hadn’t comprehended how much better Trump
was likely to do on Election Day. “Being able to document how big the absentee wave
would be and the variance by state was essential,” the analyst says.

#### PEOPLE POWER

The racial-justice uprising sparked by George Floyd’s killing in May was not primarily
a political movement. The organizers who helped lead it wanted to harness its momentum
for the election without allowing it to be co-opted by politicians. Many of those
organizers were part of Podhorzer’s network, from the activists in battleground 
states who partnered with the Democracy Defense Coalition to organizations with 
leading roles in the Movement for Black Lives.

The best way to ensure people’s voices were heard, they decided, was to protect 
their ability to vote. “We started thinking about a program that would complement
the traditional election-protection area but also didn’t rely on calling the police,”
says Nelini Stamp, the Working Families Party’s national organizing director. They
created a force of “election defenders” who, unlike traditional poll watchers, were
trained in de-escalation techniques. During early voting and on Election Day, they
surrounded lines of voters in urban areas with a “joy to the polls” effort that 
turned the act of casting a ballot into a street party. Black organizers also recruited
thousands of poll workers to ensure polling places would stay open in their communities.

The summer uprising had shown that people power could have a massive impact. Activists
began preparing to reprise the demonstrations if Trump tried to steal the election.“
Americans plan widespread protests if Trump interferes with election,” Reuters reported
in October, one of many such stories. More than 150 liberal groups, from the Women’s
March to the Sierra Club to Color of Change, from Democrats.com to the Democratic
Socialists of America, joined the “Protect the Results” coalition. The group’s now
defunct website had a map listing 400 planned postelection demonstrations, to be
activated via text message as soon as Nov. 4. To stop the coup they feared, the 
left was ready to flood the streets.

#### STRANGE BEDFELLOWS

About a week before Election Day, Podhorzer received an unexpected message: the 
U.S. Chamber of Commerce wanted to talk.

The AFL-CIO and the Chamber have a long history of antagonism. Though neither organization
is explicitly partisan, the influential business lobby has poured hundreds of millions
of dollars into Republican campaigns, just as the nation’s unions funnel hundreds
of millions to Democrats. On one side is labor, on the other management, locked 
in an eternal struggle for power and resources.

But behind the scenes, the business community was engaged in its own anxious discussions
about how the election and its aftermath might unfold. The summer’s racial-justice
protests had sent a signal to business owners too: the potential for economy-disrupting
civil disorder. “With tensions running high, there was a lot of concern about unrest
around the election, or a breakdown in our normal way we handle contentious elections,”
says Neil Bradley, the Chamber’s executive vice president and chief policy officer.
These worries had led the Chamber to release a pre-election statement with the Business
Roundtable, a Washington-based CEOs’ group, as well as associations of manufacturers,
wholesalers and retailers, calling for patience and confidence as votes were counted.

But Bradley wanted to send a broader, more bipartisan message. He reached out to
Podhorzer, through an intermediary both men declined to name. Agreeing that their
unlikely alliance would be powerful, they began to discuss a joint statement pledging
their organizations’ shared commitment to a fair and peaceful election. They chose
their words carefully and scheduled the statement’s release for maximum impact. 
As it was being finalized, Christian leaders signaled their interest in joining,
further broadening its reach.

The statement was released on Election Day, under the names of Chamber CEO Thomas
Donohue, AFL-CIO president Richard Trumka, and the heads of the National Association
of Evangelicals and the National African American Clergy Network. “It is imperative
that election officials be given the space and time to count every vote in accordance
with applicable laws,” it stated. “We call on the media, the candidates and the 
American people to exercise patience with the process and trust in our system, even
if it requires more time than usual.” The groups added, “Although we may not always
agree on desired outcomes up and down the ballot, we are united in our call for 
the American democratic process to proceed without violence, intimidation or any
other tactic that makes us weaker as a nation.”

#### SHOWING UP, STANDING DOWN

Election night began with many Democrats despairing. Trump was running ahead of 
pre-election polling, winning Florida, Ohio and Texas easily and keeping Michigan,
Wisconsin and Pennsylvania too close to call. But Podhorzer was unperturbed when
I spoke to him that night: the returns were exactly in line with his modeling. He
had been warning for weeks that Trump voters’ turnout was surging. As the numbers
dribbled out, he could tell that as long as all the votes were counted, Trump would
lose.

The liberal alliance gathered for an 11 p.m. Zoom call. Hundreds joined; many were
freaking out. “It was really important for me and the team in that moment to help
ground people in what we had already known was true,” says Angela Peoples, director
for the Democracy Defense Coalition. Podhorzer presented data to show the group 
that victory was in hand.

While he was talking, Fox News surprised everyone by calling Arizona for Biden. 
The public-awareness campaign had worked: TV anchors were bending over backward 
to counsel caution and frame the vote count accurately. The question then became
what to do next.

The conversation that followed was a difficult one, led by the activists charged
with the protest strategy. “We wanted to be mindful of when was the right time to
call for moving masses of people into the street,” Peoples says. As much as they
were eager to mount a show of strength, mobilizing immediately could backfire and
put people at risk. Protests that devolved into violent clashes would give Trump
a pretext to send in federal agents or troops as he had over the summer. And rather
than elevate Trump’s complaints by continuing to fight him, the alliance wanted 
to send the message that the people had spoken.

So the word went out: stand down. Protect the Results announced that it would “not
be activating the entire national mobilization network today, but remains ready 
to activate if necessary.” On Twitter, outraged progressives wondered what was going
on. Why wasn’t anyone trying to stop Trump’s coup? Where were all the protests?

Podhorzer credits the activists for their restraint. “They had spent so much time
getting ready to hit the streets on Wednesday. But they did it,” he says. “Wednesday
through Friday, there was not a single Antifa vs. Proud Boys incident like everyone
was expecting. And when that didn’t materialize, I don’t think the Trump campaign
had a backup plan.”

Activists reoriented the Protect the Results protests toward a weekend of celebration.“
Counter their disinfo with our confidence & get ready to celebrate,” read the messaging
guidance Shenker-Osorio presented to the liberal alliance on Friday, Nov. 6. “Declare
and fortify our win. Vibe: confident, forward-looking, unified–NOT passive, anxious.”
The voters, not the candidates, would be the protagonists of the story.

The planned day of celebration happened to coincide with the election being called
on Nov. 7. Activists dancing in the streets of Philadelphia blasted Beyoncé over
an attempted Trump campaign press conference; the Trumpers’ next confab was scheduled
for Four Seasons Total Landscaping outside the city center, which activists believe
was not a coincidence. “The people of Philadelphia owned the streets of Philadelphia,”
crows the Working Families Party’s Mitchell. “We made them look ridiculous by contrasting
our joyous celebration of democracy with their clown show.”

The votes had been counted. Trump had lost. But the battle wasn’t over.

#### THE FIVE STEPS TO VICTORY

In Podhorzer’s presentations, winning the vote was only the first step to winning
the election. After that came winning the count, winning the certification, winning
the Electoral College and winning the transition–steps that are normally formalities
but that he knew Trump would see as opportunities for disruption. Nowhere would 
that be more evident than in Michigan, where Trump’s pressure on local Republicans
came perilously close to working–and where liberal and conservative pro-democracy
forces joined to counter it.

It was around 10 p.m. on election night in Detroit when a flurry of texts lit up
the phone of Art Reyes III. A busload of Republican election observers had arrived
at the TCF Center, where votes were being tallied. They were crowding the vote-counting
tables, refusing to wear masks, heckling the mostly Black workers. Reyes, a Flint
native who leads We the People Michigan, was expecting this. For months, conservative
groups had been sowing suspicion about urban vote fraud. “The language was, ‘They’re
going to steal the election; there will be fraud in Detroit,’ long before any vote
was cast,” Reyes says.

[⌊clip_image012⌉⌊clip_image012⌉[

Trump supporters seek to disrupt the vote count at Detroit’s TCF Center on Nov. 
4
Elaine Cromie—Getty Images

He made his way to the arena and sent word to his network. Within 45 minutes, dozens
of reinforcements had arrived. As they entered the arena to provide a counterweight
to the GOP observers inside, Reyes took down their cell-phone numbers and added 
them to a massive text chain. Racial-justice activists from Detroit Will Breathe
worked alongside suburban women from Fems for Dems and local elected officials. 
Reyes left at 3 a.m., handing the text chain over to a disability activist.

As they mapped out the steps in the election-certification process, activists settled
on a strategy of foregrounding the people’s right to decide, demanding their voices
be heard and calling attention to the racial implications of disenfranchising Black
Detroiters. They flooded the Wayne County canvassing board’s Nov. 17 certification
meeting with on-message testimony; despite a Trump tweet, the Republican board members
certified Detroit’s votes.

Election boards were one pressure point; another was GOP-controlled legislatures,
who Trump believed could declare the election void and appoint their own electors.
And so the President invited the GOP leaders of the Michigan legislature, House 
Speaker Lee Chatfield and Senate majority leader Mike Shirkey, to Washington on 
Nov. 20.

It was a perilous moment. If Chatfield and Shirkey agreed to do Trump’s bidding,
Republicans in other states might be similarly bullied. “I was concerned things 
were going to get weird,” says Jeff Timmer, a former Michigan GOP chair turned anti-
Trump activist. Norm Eisen describes it as “the scariest moment” of the entire election.

The democracy defenders launched a full-court press. Protect Democracy’s local contacts
researched the lawmakers’ personal and political motives. Issue One ran television
ads in Lansing. The Chamber’s Bradley kept close tabs on the process. Wamp, the 
former Republican Congressman, called his former colleague Mike Rogers, who wrote
an op-ed for the Detroit newspapers urging officials to honor the will of the voters.
Three former Michigan governors–Republicans John Engler and Rick Snyder and Democrat
Jennifer Granholm–jointly called for Michigan’s electoral votes to be cast free 
of pressure from the White House. Engler, a former head of the Business Roundtable,
made phone calls to influential donors and fellow GOP elder statesmen who could 
press the lawmakers privately.

The pro-democracy forces were up against a Trumpified Michigan GOP controlled by
allies of Ronna McDaniel, the Republican National Committee chair, and Betsy DeVos,
the former Education Secretary and a member of a billionaire family of GOP donors.
On a call with his team on Nov. 18, Bassin vented that his side’s pressure was no
match for what Trump could offer. “Of course he’s going to try to offer them something,”
Bassin recalls thinking. “Head of the Space Force! Ambassador to wherever! We can’t
compete with that by offering carrots. We need a stick.”

If Trump were to offer something in exchange for a personal favor, that would likely
constitute bribery, Bassin reasoned. He phoned Richard Primus, a law professor at
the University of Michigan, to see if Primus agreed and would make the argument 
publicly. Primus said he thought the meeting itself was inappropriate, and got to
work on an op-ed for Politico warning that the state attorney general–a Democrat–
would have no choice but to investigate. When the piece posted on Nov. 19, the attorney
general’s communications director tweeted it. Protect Democracy soon got word that
the lawmakers planned to bring lawyers to the meeting with Trump the next day.

Reyes’ activists scanned flight schedules and flocked to the airports on both ends
of Shirkey’s journey to D.C., to underscore that the lawmakers were being scrutinized.
After the meeting, the pair announced they’d pressed the President to deliver COVID
relief for their constituents and informed him they saw no role in the election 
process. Then they went for a drink at the Trump hotel on Pennsylvania Avenue. A
street artist projected their images onto the outside of the building along with
the words THE WORLD IS WATCHING.

That left one last step: the state canvassing board, made up of two Democrats and
two Republicans. One Republican, a Trumper employed by the DeVos family’s political
nonprofit, was not expected to vote for certification. The other Republican on the
board was a little-known lawyer named Aaron Van Langevelde. He sent no signals about
what he planned to do, leaving everyone on edge.

When the meeting began, Reyes’s activists flooded the livestream and filled Twitter
with their hashtag, #alleyesonmi. A board accustomed to attendance in the single
digits suddenly faced an audience of thousands. In hours of testimony, the activists
emphasized their message of respecting voters’ wishes and affirming democracy rather
than scolding the officials. Van Langevelde quickly signaled he would follow precedent.
The vote was 3-0 to certify; the other Republican abstained.

After that, the dominoes fell. Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and the rest of the states
certified their electors. Republican officials in Arizona and Georgia stood up to
Trump’s bullying. And the Electoral College voted on schedule on Dec. 14.

#### HOW CLOSE WE CAME

There was one last milestone on Podhorzer’s mind: Jan. 6. On the day Congress would
meet to tally the electoral count, Trump summoned his supporters to D.C. for a rally.

Much to their surprise, the thousands who answered his call were met by virtually
no counterdemonstrators. To preserve safety and ensure they couldn’t be blamed for
any mayhem, the activist left was “strenuously discouraging counter activity,” Podhorzer
texted me the morning of Jan. 6, with a crossed-fingers emoji.

Trump addressed the crowd that afternoon, peddling the lie that lawmakers or Vice
President Mike Pence could reject states’ electoral votes. He told them to go to
the Capitol and “fight like hell.” Then he returned to the White House as they sacked
the building. As lawmakers fled for their lives and his own supporters were shot
and trampled, Trump praised the rioters as “very special.”

It was his final attack on democracy, and once again, it failed. By standing down,
the democracy campaigners outfoxed their foes. “We won by the skin of our teeth,
honestly, and that’s an important point for folks to sit with,” says the Democracy
Defense Coalition’s Peoples. “There’s an impulse for some to say voters decided 
and democracy won. But it’s a mistake to think that this election cycle was a show
of strength for democracy. It shows how vulnerable democracy is.”

The members of the alliance to protect the election have gone their separate ways.
The Democracy Defense Coalition has been disbanded, though the Fight Back Table 
lives on. Protect Democracy and the good-government advocates have turned their 
attention to pressing reforms in Congress. Left-wing activists are pressuring the
newly empowered Democrats to remember the voters who put them there, while civil
rights groups are on guard against further attacks on voting. Business leaders denounced
the Jan. 6 attack, and some say they will no longer donate to lawmakers who refused
to certify Biden’s victory. Podhorzer and his allies are still holding their Zoom
strategy sessions, gauging voters’ views and developing new messages. And Trump 
is in Florida, facing his second impeachment, deprived of the Twitter and Facebook
accounts he used to push the nation to its breaking point.

As I was reporting this article in November and December, I heard different claims
about who should get the credit for thwarting Trump’s plot. Liberals argued the 
role of bottom-up people power shouldn’t be overlooked, particularly the contributions
of people of color and local grassroots activists. Others stressed the heroism of
GOP officials like Van Langevelde and Georgia secretary of state Brad Raffensperger,
who stood up to Trump at considerable cost. The truth is that neither likely could
have succeeded without the other. “It’s astounding how close we came, how fragile
all this really is,” says Timmer, the former Michigan GOP chair. “It’s like when
Wile E. Coyote runs off the cliff–if you don’t look down, you don’t fall. Our democracy
only survives if we all believe and don’t look down.”

Democracy won in the end. The will of the people prevailed. But it’s crazy, in retrospect,
that this is what it took to put on an election in the United States of America.

–With reporting by LESLIE DICKSTEIN, MARIAH ESPADA and SIMMONE SHAH

_Correction appended, Feb. 4: The original version of this story misstated the name
of Norm Eisen’s organization. It is the Voter Protection Program, not the Voter 
Protection Project._

_This appears in the February 15, 2021 issue of TIME._
