# Not till the Fat lady Dances

- Link: https://kendreger.com/?p=294
- Published: 2019-12-25T07:26:00+07:00
- Author: ken

Now that the House of Representatives has voted to impeach President Donald Trump,
what is the constitutional status of the two articles of impeachment? Must they 
be transmitted to the Senate to trigger a trial, or could they be held back by the
House until the Senate decides what the trial will look like, as Speaker Nancy Pelosi
has hinted?

The Constitution doesn’t say how fast the articles must go to the Senate. Some modest
delay is not inconsistent with the Constitution, or how both chambers usually work.

But an indefinite delay would pose a serious problem. Impeachment as contemplated
by the Constitution does not consist merely of the vote by the House, but of the
process of sending the articles to the Senate for trial. Both parts are necessary
to make an impeachment under the Constitution: The House must actually send the 
articles and send managers to the Senate to prosecute the impeachment. And the Senate
must actually hold a trial.

If the House does not communicate its impeachment to the Senate, it hasn’t actually
impeached the president. If the articles are not transmitted, Trump could legitimately
say that he wasn’t truly impeached at all.

That’s because “impeachment” under the Constitution means the House sending its 
approved articles of to the Senate, with House managers standing up in the Senate
and saying the president is impeached.

As for the headlines we saw after the House vote saying, “TRUMP IMPEACHED,” those
are a media shorthand, not a technically correct legal statement. So far, the House
has voted to impeach (future tense) Trump. He isn’t impeached (past tense) until
the articles go to the Senate and the House members deliver the message.

Once the articles are sent, the Senate has a constitutional duty to hold a trial
on the impeachment charges presented. Failure for the Senate to hold a trial after
impeachment would deviate from the Constitution’s clear expectation.

For the House to vote “to impeach” without ever sending the articles of impeachment
to the Senate for trial would also deviate from the constitutional protocol. It 
would mean that the president had not genuinely been impeached under the Constitution;
and it would also deny the president the chance to defend himself in the Senate 
that the Constitution provides.

The relevant constitutional provisions are brief. Article I gives the House “the
sole power of impeachment.” And it gives the Senate “the sole power to try all impeachments.”
Article II says that the president “shall be removed from office on impeachment 
for, and conviction of, treason, bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.”

Putting these three different provisions together yields the conclusion that the
only way to remove the president while he is in office is if the House impeaches
him and the Senate tries and convicts him.

The provisions say nothing about timing. Taken literally, they don’t directly say
that articles of impeachment passed by the House must be sent to the Senate. But
the framers’ definition of impeachment assumed that impeachment was a process, not
just a House vote.

The framers drafted the constitutional provisions against the backdrop of impeachment
as it had been practiced in England, where the House of Commons impeached and the
House of Lords tried the impeachments. The whole point of impeachment by the Commons
was for the charges of impeachment to be brought against the accused in the House
of Lords.

Strictly speaking, “impeachment” occurred – and occurs — when the articles of impeachment
are presented to the Senate for trial. And at that point, the Senate is obliged 
by the Constitution to hold a trial.

What would make that trial fair is a separate question, one that deserves its own
discussion. But we can say with some confidence that only the Senate is empowered
to judge the fairness of its own trial – that’s what the “sole power to try all 
impeachments” means.

If the House votes to “impeach” but doesn’t send the articles to the Senate or send
impeachment managers there to carry its message, it hasn’t directly violated the
text of the Constitution. But the House would be acting against the implicit logic
of the Constitution’s description of impeachment.

A president who has been genuinely impeached must constitutionally have the opportunity
to defend himself before the Senate. That’s built into the constitutional logic 
of impeachment, which demands a trial before removal.

To be sure, if the House just never sends its articles of impeachment to the Senate,
there can be no trial there. That’s what the “sole power to impeach” means.

But if the House never sends the articles, then Trump could say with strong justification
that he was never actually impeached. And that’s probably not the message Congressional
Democrats are hoping to send.
