# Watergate-on-Steroids, or #ObamaGate

- Link: https://kendreger.com/?p=195
- Published: 2017-03-05T09:32:00+07:00
- Author: ken

##### Yes, There Could Be Serious Legal Problems if Obama Admin Involved in Illegal Surveillance

by [Robert Barnes](http://lawnewz.com/author/robertn/) | 3:45 pm, March 4th, 2017

[⌊submit to reddit⌉⌊submit to reddit⌉[

![](http://static03.mediaite.com/ln/up/2017/02/Obama-2-6-e1486411130362.jpg)

President Trump recently tweeted claiming that former President Obama wiretapped
him during his campaign. One can only imagine how nuts the media would have gone
if the roles had been reversed: President Trump wiretapping either Obama or the 
Clintons, though his DOJ could have authority to do just that given the expansive
leaks of intelligence information by Obama and Clinton supporters the last few months.
Heck, he could wiretap the media at this point, legally and legitimately, as the
sources of these unlawful leaks, for which Obama himself set precedent. Do liberals
understand what Pandora’s Box Obama opened up by Obama using the powers of the NSA,
CIA and FBI to spy on his political opponents? Even Nixon never did that.

**_If the stories are correct,_** Obama or his officials might even face prosecution.
But, we are still early in all of this and there are a lot of rumors flying around
so the key is if the reports are accurate. We just don’t know at this time. The 
stories currently are three-fold: first, that Obama’s team tried to get a warrant
from a regular, Article III federal court on Trump, and was told no by someone along
the way (maybe the FBI), as the evidence was that weak or non-existent; second, 
Obama’s team then tried to circumvent the federal judiciary’s independent role by
trying to mislabel the issue one of “foreign agents,” and tried to obtain a warrant
from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act “courts”, and were again turned down,
when the court saw Trump named (an extremely rare act of FISA court refusal of the
government, suggesting the evidence was truly non-existent against Trump); and so,
third, Obama circumvented both the regular command of the FBI and the regularly 
appointed federal courts, by placing the entire case as a FISA case (and apparently
under Sally Yates at DOJ) as a “foreign” case, and then omitted Trump’s name from
a surveillance warrant submitted to the FISA court, which the FISA court unwittingly
granted, which Obama then misused to spy on Trump and many connected to Trump. Are
these allegations true? We don’t know yet, but if any part of them are than Obama
and/or his officials could face serious trouble.

**Can a President be charged with a crime?** Only once out of office. While in office,
impeachment remains the exclusive remedy in order to avoid a single judicial branch
trying to overturn an election, such as a grand jury in any part of the country 
could. Once out of office, a President remains immune from civil liability for his
duties while President, under a 1982 decision of the United States Supreme Court.
However, as the Nixon pardon attests, nothing forecloses a criminal prosecution 
of the President after his presidency is complete for crimes against the country.
Obama, the Constitutional lawyer, should know that.

**What crimes could have been committed?** Ironically, for Democrats[ falsely accusing Attorney General Sessions, perjury and conspiracy to commit perjury](http://lawnewz.com/high-profile/sorry-but-jeff-sessions-absolutely-did-not-perjure-himself-under-oath-when-asked-about-russia/),
as well as intentional violations of FISA. Rather shockingly, no law currently forbids
misusing the power of the presidency to spy on one’s adversaries. What the law does
forbid is lying to any judicial officer to obtain any means of surveillance. What
the law does forbid, under criminal penalty, is the misuse of FISA. Both derive 
from the protections of the Fourth Amendment itself. Under section 1809, FISA makes
it a crime for anyone to either “engage in” electronic surveillance under “color
of law” under FISA without following the law’s restrictions, or “disclose” or “use”
information gathered from it in contravention of the statute’s sharp constrictions.

FISA, 50 USC 1801, et seq., is a very limited method of obtaining surveillance authority.
The reason for its strict limits is that FISA evades the regular federal court process,
by not allowing regularly, Constitutionally appointed federal judges and their magistrates
to authorize surveillance the Fourth Amendment would otherwise forbid. Instead, 
the Chief Justice handpicks the FISA court members, who have shown an exceptional
deference to the executive branch. This is because FISA court members trust the 
government is only bringing them surveillance about pending terror attacks or “grave
hostile” war-like attacks, as the FISA statute limits itself to. Thus, a FISA application
can only be used in very limited circumstances.

One important reminder about electronic surveillance. Occasionally, a law enforcement
officer will hear or see or record information not allowed by the warrant, but incidental
or accidental to otherwise lawful surveillance. Their job is to immediately stop
listening, stop recording, and to delete such information. This is what you occasionally
see in films where the agent in the van hears the conversation turn away from something
criminal to a personal discussion, and the agent then turns off the listening device
and stops the recording. Such films simply recognize long-standing legal practice.

**_FISA can only be used for “foreign intelligence information.”_** Now that sounds
broad, but is in fact very limited under the law. The only “foreign intelligence
information” allowed as a basis for surveillance is information necessary to protect
the United States against actual or potential “grave” “hostile” attack, war-like
sabotage or international terror. **_Second_**, it can only be used to eavesdrop
on conversations where the parties to the conversation are a foreign power or an
agent of a foreign power. An agent of a foreign power cannot be a United States 
person unless they are knowingly involved in criminal espionage. No warrant is allowed
on that person unless a FISA court finds probable cause the United States person
is knowingly engaged in criminal espionage. Even then, if it involves a United States
person, special steps must be taken to “minimize the acquisition and retention, 
and prohibit the dissemination, of non publicly available information concerning
un-consenting United States persons.”

This includes procedures that require they never identify the person, or the conversation,
being surveilled, to the public where that information is not evidence of a particular
crime. **_Third_**, the kind of information sought concerns solely information about
a pending or actual attack on the country. That is why the law limits itself to 
sabotage incidents involving war, not any form or kind of “sabotage,” explicitly
limiting itself to those acts identified in section 105 of Title 18 of the United
States Code.

**_NOTE:_** This bring us to Watergate-on-Steroids, or #ObamaGate. Here are the 
problematic aspects of the Obama surveillance on Trump’s team, and on Trump himself.**
First,** it is not apparent FISA could ever be invoked. **Second**, it is possible
Obama’s team may have perjured themselves before the FISA court by withholding material
information essential to the FISA court’s willingness to permit the government surveillance.
Third, it could be that Obama’s team illegally disseminated and disclosed FISA information
in direct violation of the statute precisely prohibiting such dissemination and 
disclosure. FISA prohibits, under criminal penalty, Obama’s team from doing any 
of the three.

At the outset, the NSA should have never been involved in a domestic US election.
Investigating the election, or any hacking of the DNC or the phishing of Podesta’s
emails, would not be a FISA matter. It does not fit the definition of war sabotage
or a “grave” “hostile” war-like attack on the United States, as constrictively covered
by FISA. It is your run-of-the-mill hacking case covered by existing United States
laws that require use of the regular departments of the FBI, Department of Justice,
and Constitutionally Senate-appointed federal district court judges, and their appointed
magistrates, not secretive, deferential FISA courts.

Out of 35,000+ requests for surveillance, the FISA court has only ever rejected 
a whopping 12. Apparently, according to published reports, you can add one more 
to that — even the FISA court first rejected Obama’s request to spy on Trump’s team
under the guise of an investigation into foreign agents of a pending war attack,
intelligence agents apparently returned to the court, where, it is my assumption,
that they did not disclose or divulge all material facts to the court when seeking
the surveillance the second time around, some of which they would later wrongfully
disseminate and distribute to the public. By itself, misuse of FISA procedures to
obtain surveillance is itself, a crime.

**_This raises the second problem:_** Obama’s team submission of an affidavit to
to the FISA court. An application for a warrant of any kind requires an affidavit,
and that affidavit may not omit material factors. A fact is “material” if it could
have the possible impact of impacting the judicial officer deciding whether to authorize
the warrant. Such affidavits are the most carefully drawn up, reviewed, and approved
affidavits of law enforcement in our system precisely because they must be fully-
disclosing, forthcoming, and include any information a judge must know to decide
whether to allow our government to spy on its own. My assumption would be that intelligence
officials were trying to investigate hacking of DNC which is not even a FISA covered
crime, so therefore serious questions arise about what Obama administration attorneys
said to the FISA court to even consider the application. If the claim was “financial
ties” to Russia, then Obama knew he had no basis to use FISA at all.

Since Trump was the obvious target, the alleged failure to disclose his name in 
the second application could be a serious and severe violation of the obligation
to disclose all material facts. Lastly, given the later behavior, it is evident 
any promise in the affidavit to protect the surveilled information from ever being
sourced or disseminated was a false promise, intended to induce the illicit surveillance.
This is criminalized both by federal perjury statutes, conspiracy statutes, and 
the FISA criminal laws themselves.

That raises the **_third problem_**: it seems the FISA-compelled protocols for precluding
the dissemination of the information were violated, and that Obama’s team issued
orders to achieve precisely what the law forbids,[ if published reports are true about the administration sharing the surveilled information far-and-wide to promote unlawful leaks to the press.](https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/01/us/politics/obama-trump-russia-election-hacking.html?_r=0)
This, too, would be its own crime, as it brings back the ghost of Hillary’s emails—
by definition, FISA information is strictly confidential or it’s information that
never should have been gathered. FISA strictly segregates its surveilled information
into two categories: highly confidential information of the most serious of crimes
involving foreign acts of war; or, if not that, then information that should never
have been gathered, should be immediately deleted, and never sourced nor disseminated.
It cannot be both.

Recognizing this information did not fit FISA meant having to delete it and destroy
it. According to published reports, Obama’s team did the opposite: order it preserved,
ordered the NSA to search it, keep it, and share it; and then Obama’s Attorney General
issued an order to allow broader sharing of information and, according to the New
York Times, Obama aides acted to label the Trump information at a lower level of
classification for massive-level sharing of the information. The problem for Obama
is simple — if it could fit a lower level of classification, then it had to be deleted
and destroyed, not disseminated and distributed, under crystal clear FISA law. Obama’s
team’s admission it could be classified lower, yet taking actions to insure its 
broadest distribution, could even put Obama smack-middle of the biggest unlawful
surveillance and political-opponent-smear campaign since Nixon. Except even Nixon
didn’t use the FBI and NSA for his dirty tricks.

Watergate would have never happened if Nixon felt like he could just ask the FBI
or NSA to tape the calls. This is Hoover-esque abuses of the kind Bob Woodward pal,
former FBI Assistant Director Mark Felt (otherwise known as Deep Throat), routinely
engaged in at the FBI until convicted and removed from office. (You didn’t know 
that Deep Throat was really a corrupt part of Deep State, did you? Guess who ran
the famous COINTELPRO? That’s right — Deep Throat. How would the public have reacted
if they knew the media had been in bed with the deep state all the way back then?
Maybe that was the reason Woodward, Bernstein and Bradley kept Deep Throat’s identity
secret all those years?)

Democrats may regret Sessions’ recusal, as his replacement is a mini-Sessions: a
long-respected, a-political, highly ethical prosecutor, Dana Boente, whose reputation
is well-warranted from his service at the Tax Division, and who won’t be limited
by any perceived ties to Trump, given his prior appointment by Obama. Obama himself
appeared scared of Boente, as he removed Boente from the successor-to-Sessions position
during the lame-duck part of Obama’s presidency, but Trump restored Boente to that
role earlier this month. Democrats may get the investigation they wanted, but it
may be their own that end up named in the indictment.

_[Robert Barnes is a California-based trial attorney](http://www.barneslawllp.com/about/)
whose practice focuses on tax defense, civil rights and First Amendment law. You
can follow him at [@Barnes\_Law](https://twitter.com/Barnes_Law)_
